The first and most important thing to understand, IMO, is how important our view is. We are german car enthusiasts. We love cars. And a lot of us love BMW. If someone comes and says we just a bunch of freaks on a forum, to hell with him/her (not saying this for SCOTT). It is important as a consumer to give the feedback to the brand executives. And I am sure someone at BMW reads this.
We all said back in the day the F20 1er front looked like crap. If the designer of the car had been here, he would have given us a proper explanation about why the front was like this. Kind of the same way Scott tryed to deffend it. Well, in the end, it does not matter. We did not like it. And still don´t. And guess who was right? US. BMW has now changed the front end because it was true it looked like crap. And the LCI will bring a much improved design.
Regarding this 7er. BMW had the pieces. They created a couple of concepts with interesting design ideas, but in the end they sticked with the same old ones. There is nothing from the VFL on this car. As I said to
@tomazino a few weeks back, it is the same case as with the CS. We were told we would love the F01 if we liked the CS. Well, there was very little of the CS in the F01 design. Almost nothing bare a couple design ideas. Why BMW does not try with some angular hoff kink? Or offer some variation on their well-known straight shoulder line? They have featured this on both the CS and the VFL, yet it never reaches production. We have the same side profile, exactly the same side profile, with a softer shoulder line on the rear part, no double hoff kink this time, no lower profile crease, and instead more chrome. Well, OK, it´s not an improvement. It´s just playing with the same pieces. Changing creases for chrome. Simpler and less risky design.
The rear end is the one that deserves more credit. Even when it looks to alike the current BMW line up, at least it offer some changes. What about the front end? Achange in the hood line, a 6er-like front bumper, and the same dull looking frontlights that are connected to the grille. Headlights that look like a tube with a kink at the end. Again, not enough. And I say more, it looks worse than the F01´s front end.
And the interior. The interior will have fantastic materials, nice tech, and everything that is expected on a car like this. The problem is two years ago, MB stepped up the game. Audi seems to know this and the appear to be heading the same direction. And the have Bentley there, and Porsche. You cannot have you flagship´s interior influenced by the lower end sedan (3er). Specially when the F30´s interior is nothing to writte about (to be politically correct). Just look at how the A8 and S-Class door panels look and then look at this. It is clearly not enough. And if you don´t want to look at the competitors, go and compare the G11 doors with the F01 or the F15 X5. This interior would be fantastic on the G30 5er. But it falls short on the 7er.
As I have said, I don´t think this car is a disaster. I don´t think BMW needs a change of head designer. It is just that this model is not enough to top the W222 S-Class in terms of design, and will probably be worse when the new A8 comes. There is no shock to the public. Nothing exciting to look about. And I think this segment is all about this. E65 was a shock back in 2001 (it was not a beauty, but it had something new that shocked the audience).
The other day some people laughed when I said BMW needed a pair of balls sometimes. Well, I bet I won´t be the only one to think that when this car hits the streets.
But, as I have said, I think the G30 5er will be everything this 7er is not.