The best interior out of the 3 big Germans?
- Thread starter Tumbo
- Start date
Merc1
Premium
yeap, i can't argue with that
Nothing against other models, but i hate, HATE the fact that S's and CL's interiors are identical! They can be built on the same platform, but come on... There should be difference between those two, but i'm sorry, i don't see any of it.
The difference between the S and the CL is noticable, although MB can try harder, but look at BMW their 3 series sedan and coupe interior is exactly the same. the 3 series coupe dashboard design is very ugly, and it doesn't suit the sporting nature of the car.
PanterroR
Lap Time Luminary
Hardly...Copy and paste (Microsoft accent)
.Agreed (only not that it's ugly
)! The only difference between MB's sedan and coupe (S & CL) and 3er (coupe and sedan) is that CL is way more exclusive than 3er coupe is from sedan, so that's why i think it should be different. And i'm sure there are others that'll agree. Heck, 335i is 335i by sedan and coupe, and by MB it's S600 and CL600 for example, the name is different too.
Just my opinion.
Agreed (only not that it's ugly
I agree with you, i think MB realise this problem with the S and the CL, that is why their Ocean Drive concept has more different dashboard design than the S , even though the layout is pretty much the same. Maybe the facelift S will incoperate these styling changes
PanterroR
Lap Time Luminary
Merc1
Premium
Heck, 335i is 335i by sedan and coupe, and by MB it's S600 and CL600 for example, the name is different too.
Funny man.
BMW just dropped the "Ci" designation a with this generation of 3 Coupe. The CL and 3-Coupe are just coupe versions of their respective sedans regardless of how they label them. Seriously though, there is hardly a "problem" with the CL and S-Class interior looking alike. The CL makes up for it with a stunning exterior!
M
PanterroR
Lap Time Luminary
Funny man.
No need for that "C" letter, unless you're blind to see the difference between Sedan and Coupe... Maybe for you MB guys; your beloved brand created complete mess with that "sedan with coupe lines" - aka CLS...
Agreed!
For me it is; not that i care 'cause i'd buy one and that it bothers me, no. Simply, there should be a considerable difference. There's a big difference in sales between those two, right?
Poverty
Oversteer Expert
Having recently visited all 3 dealerships its a easy choice for me, and this is coming from an MB fan.
1. Audi (easily, the S8 interior is even much better than the new s-class)
2. MB (just ahead of BMW, some models let it down.)
3. BMW (some models have rather poor interiors, inregards for the asking price such as the M5, and the 3er ES.)
1. Audi (easily, the S8 interior is even much better than the new s-class)
2. MB (just ahead of BMW, some models let it down.)
3. BMW (some models have rather poor interiors, inregards for the asking price such as the M5, and the 3er ES.)
bmer
Tire Trailblazer
My take:
1. Audi (the most classic and beautiful designs, never lets down with overall look.)
2. BMW/Mercedes (At first the new design line of BMW was shocking. Now after few years I'm used to the sharp edges, asymmetric lines and the simplified design. The enhancement with E92/E93 and E70 X5 is a good direction for the interior design of BMW.)
(Mercedes has some very beautiful interiors but the latest designs are a bit two-sided. The quality is very fine but there are always some elements that could have been better like the steering wheel (S, CL, new C) for example.)
1. Audi (the most classic and beautiful designs, never lets down with overall look.)
2. BMW/Mercedes (At first the new design line of BMW was shocking. Now after few years I'm used to the sharp edges, asymmetric lines and the simplified design. The enhancement with E92/E93 and E70 X5 is a good direction for the interior design of BMW.)
(Mercedes has some very beautiful interiors but the latest designs are a bit two-sided. The quality is very fine but there are always some elements that could have been better like the steering wheel (S, CL, new C) for example.)
Fit and finish: im not sure its a draw between MB and audi..as my experiences with audi interiors have been far from what is told here..
for example a driver seat in a new RS4 that squeeks so much you have to turn up the stereo loud to drown it..
and for MB they have had some serious probs lately..but these new cars..especially the S class..are freakin amazing..like a vault.. go and try if you dont belive it
Design: Here MB winns it for me.. i hate BMW interior design..with its sharp edges..and failed attempts to try to be hyper modern..
they should take their design back to Z8 interior time.. hoping for new cool direction with the new 7er..
Audi on the other hand always look nice..but thats about it.. nothing spectacular.. very strict.. and german.. and i hate the similarites that runs all trough the VAG interior line up..its disturbing..
Ergonomics: BMW sucks arse in this department.. they really need to think this over.. seems like they did with the X5 wich seems to have a hot interior.. Audi cars have good ergonomics.. nothing is placed in a wierd place.. everything is easy to reach and use..
But MB gives me this feeling..especially the S class..that the car works for you.. everything seems so automatic and naturall..
they are the true masters of ergonomics.. ( on the other hand..it could be the fact that im used to MB
So MB gets my vote.. surprise surprise..
Thanks. well said, I agree.
The seat adjustment buttons are located on the door-thats what i mean.
NarutoRamen
Kraftwagen König
Makes perfect sense to me. At least you can see what you're doing. Beats having it on the bottom corner of your seat.
King-B
Fuel Gauge Fan
Design = Audi. Audi by far has the most attractive interior from a designers point of view. Everything just flows. Audi typically has the advantage mostly because their interiors look attractive online as well as in person too. Audi on the other hand still cant match Mercedes comfort level.
Quality = Mercedes. Even though Audi makes some of the most attractive interiors, Mercedes continues to raise the bar in comfort and quality. The designs however are spiritless. Like most Japanese cars. Some examples would be the new C, M, ML, and outdated E.
Ergonomics = BMW. Everybody is bashing BMW today for their "UGLY" interiors, but its clear that a lot of people haven't sat in a newer BMW. Pictures certainly don't do justice, because in person, BMW interiors just work. The Ultimate Driving Machine deserves the Ultimate Drivers Interior. BMW shouldn't settle for less.
Quality = Mercedes. Even though Audi makes some of the most attractive interiors, Mercedes continues to raise the bar in comfort and quality. The designs however are spiritless. Like most Japanese cars. Some examples would be the new C, M, ML, and outdated E.
Ergonomics = BMW. Everybody is bashing BMW today for their "UGLY" interiors, but its clear that a lot of people haven't sat in a newer BMW. Pictures certainly don't do justice, because in person, BMW interiors just work. The Ultimate Driving Machine deserves the Ultimate Drivers Interior. BMW shouldn't settle for less.
The craziest part is that BMW has the least to do to become the best at all things.
1) Jack styling cues from Audi, Layout, materials.
2) But softer leather on the seats. (Mercedes)
3) Ad the next level technology that BMW is known for!
End result, back on top IMO!
Of course! I off loaded my previous generation528i two years ago, and if I might add the end of comfortable BMW's. I was certain I was going to buy a 745Li when it was released, but I was rather disappointed with how tuff the leather was, so I got a S55AMG instead. I'm one of the very few people you'll meet who puts more stock in the interior than the exterior.
I figure you don't drive the exterior so I make my decisions accordingly.
Similar threads
- Article
