Porsche Guy
Kraftkurve King
People of course have not have driven these future turbo 911 variants, but have driven enough turbo powered cars to understand the differences and what will probably be lost if Porsche does switch to an all turbo line up. Soup, that you originally quoted, AFAIK, owned or still owns a GT2 or GT2RS. I think it is safe to say he probably has a good idea of how a turbo powered 911 drives.
As for the "bitching and moaning", others call it as expressing one's opinion. And yes, that is what usually happens in Internet forums.
As things currently stand, I'd pick NA over FI but that doesn't mean I'm not open to change. The automobile is all about change. It's just weird that in a forum dedicated to the automobile, people are so unwilling to embrace one of it's greatest attributes.