If anybody saw the latest Top Gear which was broadcast two days ago (Sunday 2nd March), then you will know that the first ten minutes was dedicated to Jeremy Clarkson comparing the BMW M135i with the VW Golf GTi.
Now, it was all going very well for the BMW until JC almost rolled it when the car suddenly veered off the runway whilst going in a straight line and whilst accelerating through 120 mph. The camera caught the on board footage and JC looked visibly shaken. I think would have been the same. From then on the BMW didn't receive a favourable review. In fact, the Golf won by a clear margin as far as JC was concerned because it didn't try to kill him.
Now, I couldn't give a toss what JC thinks of a car. I don't regard him as anything other than a TV presenter which presents a programme loosely based around cars. I don't take him seriously. But what I do care about is the truth and manipulation of the casual TV viewers. Viewers who take what JC says as gospel.
So, what is my point? Well, the weather conditions were VERY wet and JC was driving around with the traction control disabled on the M135i, so when they discussed the crash after the video was shown you'd have thought the fact that the traction control was turned off would have been mentioned wouldn't you? Well, it wasn't. Even worse, they actually edited footage of the instrument dials to HIDE the fact that the traction control was disabled. If they'd just failed to mention it then it wouldn't have been so bad, but to actually go into the video footage afterwards and EDIT the disabled traction control light out of the shot it really is deceitful and if I was BMW I would be very annoyed and would consider legal action, or at the very least issue some kind of press release. To the casual viewer the BMW was portrayed as having a tendency to just spin off the road in the wet, and not only was no mention made of the fact that the traction control was disabled, but Top Gear actually went to the trouble of even hiding it. Disgraceful.
Here are the screen shots from the programme:
First you can see the dashboard before the traction control light has been edited out. "Sport+" is selected on the DPC, which means by default the stability control is reduced, as indicated by the yellow car symbol.
In this second shot the "Sport+" is still selected on the DPC, but the yellow "reduced stability control" light has been edited out of the frame. I have checked and it is IMPOSSIBLE to have Sport+ selected and not have reduced stability. So somebody has subsequently edited the footage before broadcast.
