Re: Post by Germaniac
Rob said:
I am familiar with the "white Australia policy" -- nothing like a bit of institutionalized racism.
But I hardly see how this issue relates to workers being displaced in the West by cheap labour in third-world countries.
G'day
I think I was attempting to link the fact that in both scenarios (with the white australia policy and the current environmental debates) the same excuse is being used - "it will cost us jobs and harm industry". I drew the conclusion, based on the fact that immigration has done nothing if not benefit the Australian economy because with more people comes a greater need - that tight emission control, while in the short-term will surely affect jobs (as did mass immigration of cheap labour), will in the longer term create jobs due to the fact that the need for energy production will still be the same - it will just need to come from different (ie "green") sources, which will in turn inject investment into that industry.
I think the heart of the issue is your point "If US companies are forced to cut emissions, they will simply close down their operations in the US and move their facilities to China or other developing countries ". As I've said I'm no expert but this is my understanding of the situation - companies now require a great deal of energy (electricity, fuel etc) to operate and are basically solely reliant on fossil fuels to provide that energy (power the generators, work the machines etc). Now, your scenario is that once companies are forced to "clean up their act", they will not bother but instead ship their operations off sure to a less restricted country, costing both jobs and doing just as much harm to the environment. I just don't see this as a plausible reality, mainly because I'm under the impression companies can't just pack up and leave operations in countries like the US with they seem fit - they are inextrolibly linked or "tied down" in politics, unionism etc - think about all the trouble GM, for example, has had in recent years with laying off employees - imagine
all manufacturing companies laying off
all of their staff tomorrow - it just ain't gonna happen. Instead, I believe, companies will "swallow", forced or otherwise, the slightly higher cost of energy by buying it from green sources.. initially of course that energy will be significantly more expensive but as it is assimilated more and more it will become the new norm.