Honestly, I really hated that period for the LS. The late 2009 to September 2012 iteration above was lame duck product. The worst, next to the aesthetics of the 2000-03 period (copied C140 & W140). The LS 460 of 2006 was so clean and well executed, that the clay model from 2003 highlights my feelings on this. People called it bland and slab-sided, but I disagreed. The exterior was just
clean and
simple.
It was an
L-finessed BMW, simple as that. Very much an upsized derivative of the E60 5er BIG TIME! An indirect BMW copy, which avoided the E65, but went for its sibling (5er). Interior center stack could've been better and more substantial like later version (12+). Despite that, it sold like gangbusters at launch (rivaling W221) and was the car that made me really take the car seriously, only to let me down in 2009 and 2012 with weak or belated efforts. Lexus has never captured that LS momentum again, hoping to do so with the 2018 model.
I have said this before and I'll say it again. Toyota as parent company of Lexus, should've supported Lexus management skipping a 2010 model year WEAK refresh and instead ordered an LS big facelift in Q4 2010/Q1 2011 for the 2011 model year, a la what the 2013 model year LS mega-facelift was. They mismanaged the LS lifecycle badly, thinking they were pulling a 1994 (see '95 LS 400) with the MY 2013 car.
Sure, it wouldn't have gotten the Spindle Grille if launched as a MY 2011, but that could've been added for MY 2013 and then another light update.
This is actually how the XF40 LS life-cycle went, plus some more.
- 2001 - Start of Development of 250L Programme at Technical Centre Toyota City, Aichi and Nagoya HQ
- 2002 - Design work starts on XF40 under 250L (LS 430 facelift frozen)
- 2003 - Final Design Approved (LS 430 facelift also launched)
- 2004 - Design Freeze of XF40 at beginning of the year.
- 2005 - Prototypes spotted; LF-Sh Concept
- 2006 - Model revealed and released, planning for refresh.
- 2007 - Launch of flagship LS600h, development starts on refresh
- 2008 - Design freeze on XF40 II, launch of AWD LS 460 for MY 2009.
- 2009 - Stupid weak refresh is a terrible cost-cutting effort for MY 2010.
- 2010 - LS permanently loses U.S. sales crown to MB, over cheapened LS for MY 2010. (XF40 III Mega-Facelift design approved)
- 2011 - LS falls to third place in US sales, via new F01 7er expansion. (Prototypes of XF40 III are tested at Hokkaido and HQ) 200B programme is greenlighted.
- 2012 - Full development of 200B programme commences in January 2012, XF40 III prototypes hit the roads and teasers are released in January 2012. XF40 III revealed in July, sold from September.
- 2013 - Styling begins to conclude on 200B programme by December.
- 2014 - Design of XF50 LS is frozen on June 27, 2014, major updates introduced for MY 2015 XF40 in autumn. First XF50 prototypes built and is shown privately to select audiences in Fall 2014.
- 2015 - First 200B mules caught testing. Cancelling of mainline V8 offering for 200B. Minor changes for MY 2016 in autumn.
- 2016 - First 200B prototypes of XF50 spotted in public in July.
- 2017 - Successor XF50 revealed and XF40 ends production in Q3, after 11 years.
This is how the life-cycle should've been, accounting for delays:
- 2006 - LS 460 Launch
- 2007 - LS 600h Launch
- 2008 - Minor updates for MY 2009
- 2009 - No changes for MY 2010
- 2010 - Major facelift for MY 2011 in Q4 2010.
- 2011 - Or Major facelift for MY 2011 in Q1 2011. No changes or little amount for MY 2012.
- 2012 - Moderate changes for MY 2013 in late 2012.
- 2013 - Minor refresh for MY 2014 to add Spindle Grille, prepare transition to XF50.
- 2014 - No changes for MY '15
- 2015 - Standardized equipment for MY 2016
- 2016 - Redesigned LS revealed in Paris for Q2 2017 launch as 2017.5.
My biggest issue was how weak and lazy the MY 2010 LS facelift was, resulting in so many segment customers dismissing it over the bold step forward with the 2007 MY car. Mostly in favour of the very much improved W221 facelift for MY 2010, that felt solidly Mercedes for once, than rebound MB/high-end Chrysler. (I really did not like pre-facelift W221 in reg guise) Plus that of the new F01, which did even better with sub-750i's in the U.S. market like 740i and hybrid.
Toyota killed the momemtum for the LS with a weak first refresh and that of keeping it past its sell-by date