Vs Car and Driver: A8 vs 750i, vs S550 vs LS460 vs XJ8 Super V8

[Matt]

I wouldnt be bothered by what those auto spies members say. It seems that they make dumb and presumptuous comments pretty often..

 

[Bruce]

I forgot to mention that they said the S had excess torque, probably due to it out displacing the others by atleast a litre.

Ok, that comment takes the championship of stupidity! What the hell?!

 

[GTA45E]

Yet another victory for the S-Class. It sits on top of the world now!

 

[cawimmer430]

The Lexus fanboys on Autospies are claiming that the Lexus LS460 used in the C&D comparison was a pre-production model. Yeah, whatever. These guys just come up with the most lame excuses.

The placements of these cars is firstly do to their performance, and second because of editor opinions. If the editors liked the cars, they got top marks. If there was something not to like, the car got the appropriate marks. All cars in this class are beyond perfection. It comes down to individual preference. Case closed.

 

[GTA45E]

Ok, I`ve been very busy so I just read this article today...
I must say Car&Driver has an excellent review here!! I believe that were honest. I enjoyed reading about the highs and lows of each car and how the S (the ultimate) came out on top..

 

[PHYBENZ]

I thought the article was good, but would have liked a little more in depth analysis of each car, but it was great to see the MB in first and the Lexus in last, nonetheless.