M3/M4 BMW M3 CSL: the (all too) concentrated experience


The BMW M3 is a high-performance version of the BMW 3 Series, developed by BMW's in-house motorsport division, BMW M GmbH. M3 models have been produced for every generation of 3 Series since the E30 M3 was introduced in 1986. The BMW M4 is a high-performance version of the BMW 4 Series automobile developed by BMW's motorsport division, BMW M, that has been built since 2014. As part of the renumbering that splits the coupé and convertible variants of the 3 Series into the 4 Series, the M4 replaced those variants of the BMW M3. Official website: BMW M

martinbo

Tarmac Titan
Staff member
Messages
19,875
Name
Martin
South Africans are a strange lot. They never quite caught on to the idea that an M3 CSL is a collectable and a classic keepsake of everything that epitomises BMW’s pinnacle of the straight-six sport coupé concept. Not all of the 40-odd units that were destined for our shores were even allocated and so rumour has it that only 29 examples made it into private hands. Interestingly, SA-spec cars came with full-on climate control, CD-stereo and park distance control. Not quite the essential options for a track day burner one would ask.

My M3 CSL test-drive was all too brief. This particular black car was one of 3 pristine examples on the floor at Lyndhurst BMW here in Johannesburg. After being snapped up fairly rapidly upon launch, a number of CSLs were just as quickly let go by their new owners for reasons that are unclear to me. The original going rate was R 940,000.00 and today a CSL can be had for between R 570,000.00 to R 650,000.00. Not the residuals you’d expect from a future classic. Did this situation result from the car being different to what prospective owners imagined? I can only guess. Fortunately for me, the M3 CSL is now a known quantity and I had a pretty good idea of what to expect thanks to friend of mine and you folks here at GCF.

So, with the fuel light lit and only 27 km of computed range to go, I fired the beast up, marvelled at the drama of the thing just at idle alone (would you believe), snicked the lever across into drive and selected first gear with the right steering mounted paddle. Moving off simply requires a gentle dab on the accelerator followed by the briefest of pauses before the clutch bites and the car gets away cleanly. Careful to wait for optimum engine temperature and mindful of my lack of experience (relative to my AWD experience) with a powerful rear-wheel car I took things easy for the first part of the drive. Gearbox set to slush mode and partial throttle loads didn’t detract from the sense that this is a most intimately involving experience. The car’s ride is seriously firm (as another friend of mine puts it; drive over a 50 cent coin and you can tell whether it’s heads or tails) and there’s a distinct lack of sound deadening. This culminates in what has to be one of motoring’s finer aural experiences. What you feel and what you hear must surely be the closest thing you can get to a production race car for the (GT3 and other prancing horse types excepted I’d imagine).

The M3 CSL is all about using that 7900 rpm rev-range – it’s not a car that’s going to thrust you back into your seat at freeway speeds in the top two gears. No, for that true CSL experience, pull back on the left paddle (maybe twice even) marvel at the simply grin-inducing throttle blip upon gearing down and press the loud pedal. All the way down. The sound that the M3 CSL makes is difficult to describe; the best I can do is to say that it’s somewhere between a roar and a howl. It’s nothing short of nape-of-the-neck tingling stuff… Roooaaarrrroooowwllll, KERPOW, Roooarrrrooowwlll, KERPOW! Yup, you guessed it: in hardcore mode the gearshift is a sudden, violent and audible kick in the back. I love it because it simply compounds on the drama of the whole experience. My passenger friend winced though – so this is definitely not one for the faint-of-heart or for demurely disposed spouses. This is a man’s car and a driver’s car – period. Sure, I know a couple of ladies that’ll take to it like ducks to water, but I also know that those ladies will pretty much out-drive most of the guys I know on any given Sunday.

Truth be told, I couldn’t possibly tell you what a CSL handles like at the limit, so vast is the depth of this car’s ability. Sure, we got to take some corners and yes, the overall impression was one of immense grip, adjustability and interactivity but I’m hardly going to be the one that passes on an exact impression of the M3 CSL’s most intimate handling nuances. Suffice to say that in my experience: thank God for DSC. This is one car that truly imparts an understanding of the meaning of power. Power is the rate at which torque is delivered and in the CSL there is an overwhelming sensation of this rate increasing – as if exponentially - as the revs rise. Floor it mid corner, in the right gear, and the CSL will burn rubber baby. Novices beware.

All in all, the pervading impression is of a car that intimately (there’s that word again) interfaces the road with the driver in a sensationally tactile and visceral manner. After my experience with it, I think I have a new slogan for Bavaria’s best…

BMW: What you Feel is Real
 
Very nice review you have there Martin very nice. I love your "What you Feel is Real".

I love it

The M3 CSL is a very interesting car when you think about what it has become. We haven't really heard anything about it really, but I guess it will go down in history as one of those cars that simply was really good, but not for everyone. The car is great and all but the lack of amenities will take away from many drivers. Fortunately BMW has made cars like the M6 since then which have all the goodies and are fast as hell. Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against the CSL, it is truly a monster from what we have seen, but for the price I would rather get something else. To me the CSL look as though it was an experiment from BMW. A learning experience, not as much from a sales perspective but from a performance perspective. I am sure that BMW will follow this 'lightened' belief in his future sports cars.
 
BMWFREAK said:
The car is great and all but the lack of amenities will take away from many drivers. Fortunately BMW has made cars like the M6 since then which have all the goodies and are fast as hell. Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against the CSL, it is truly a monster from what we have seen, but for the price I would rather get something else. To me the CSL look as though it was an experiment from BMW. A learning experience, not as much from a sales perspective but from a performance perspective. I am sure that BMW will follow this 'lightened' belief in his future sports cars.

That's just it Mike, I feel you've hit the nail on the head...

[Did I mention that SA CSL's also came with electric window winders?] The CSL isn't for everyone and it most absolutely isn't an only car, everyday driver. The M3 CSL is a back to basics approach to providing a thrilling motoring experience despite its liberal use of high-tech engineering. This is not a luxury car. This is a performance car of the highest order in every discipline. I mean, it weighs less than 1400 kilo's - more than 300 less than the (altogether different) M6.

It's every bit the true enthusiast's choice, a car eminently suited to driving the dickens out of on either road or track in good conditions. And it's Nordschleife time bears testament to that. For a person like me, the luxury items in a CSL comprise the S54 engine with revised carbon fibre air box, the SMG II transmission, the powerful brakes, sumptuous steering wheel, impossibly perfect seats, CFRP roof and so on... All of these contribute, quantifiably, to delivering an exceptional motoring experience.

The M3 CSL deserves to be painstakingly cared for, covered and parked in its own Italian tiled garage for work days and unleashed when you're simply in the mood for a cracking good drive.
 
Arghh...the wimpy CSL frightened you martinbo :D , well than I supose the
GTR street-legal would have given you a heart attack...:D
Cheers you lucky b-----d.:t-drive: :t-cheers: :usa7uh:
 
Outch...:eusa_doh:
It's a Merc conspiracy to mess with me mind.

Speaking of colectors items, how 'bout a 2002 Turbo ?!

Guaranteed to turn your kidneys into punching bags and take off, literary, when the it goes beyond 3500 RPMs.
Also no need for DSG, in good 2002 Turbo fashion it's guaranteed stop into a tree, wall, car in front, or, if not, sooner or later gravity will stop it into a ditch.

Thing you can handle it ?!
 
Heh, thanks for the review, Martin! If I'd had been in a CSL for the first time, I'd take it gently as well. They aren't common cars - it'd be a shame to bend one - and every unfamiliar car deserves some respect at first meeting.

I guess that perhaps people did think it was a different beast. Perhaps there aren't enough people that would take a stripped out BMW there just to drive and race. Perhaps in time, people will look past the lack of creature comforts and see the car for its true purpose.

Hopefully BMW will still be making such cars by then.
 
Great review Martin! I was always a little dissapointed that the CSL never came to the U.S. but in hindsight, there arent enough Americans who would really use that car. They crave powerful, comfortable, luxury cars-not stripped out race cars. BMW knew this, which is why they didnt bring it here. It seems that possibly SA is similar, which is why the CSL flopped down there as well.

Thx again for the review.
 
:usa7uh: Great review Martin... What a zesty drive that was.... Mus thave felt real good afterall....
 
Snake Vargas said:
...If I'd had been in a CSL for the first time, I'd take it gently as well. They aren't common cars - it'd be a shame to bend one - and every unfamiliar car deserves some respect at first meeting.

Y'know it's a strange thing: since becoming an instructor, my whole attitude to test drives has changed. I hardly ever wring a car's neck anymore, except the odd STI and Prodrive WRX (hey, I did a write up on that for Subaru SA - interested in reading?) which are cars that I'm implicitely familiar with on road and track. As for other brands, my test drives are about doing the car due justice and making sure that I don't upset the salesperson. I hate seeing cars abused on test drives.

Snake Vargas said:
I guess that perhaps people did think it was a different beast. Perhaps there aren't enough people that would take a stripped out BMW there just to drive and race. Perhaps in time, people will look past the lack of creature comforts and see the car for its true purpose.

Hopefully BMW will still be making such cars by then.

Snake and Matt, I agree with you both on this sentiment, I think that there many wealthy people out there (with the small exception of true enthusiasts like drronh) who simply lack the apptitude or education to understand why they're puting their names down on a waiting list for a high performance car. Most of them will never reach the car's true potential and will use them instead as symbols of status and success and having the "latest & greatest".

Look, none of us are Formula 1 drivers and I'm not condemning those owners that got rid of their CSLs, I'm just saying that it would've been nice in a sentimental fashion that a halo model such as this would've been cherished by each owner for the car that it is...
 
Thanks Alex and Yannis for the kind words... Most encouraging!
 
Heh, if you're talking about test drives, then I try not to upset the salespeople either, much less do damage to the cars. Plus, if I'm going to go fast, I'd much rather do it somewhere that it's still within the legal limits.

On that note, it's not really useful for me to do anything that's too far outside the course of normal use in a car. It's not like I'm a race driver testing a car for the track. I know that my driving is really only for everyday purposes anyway.

So, maybe the joke's on everyone who buys an M3 CSL and then doesn't use it for the track. They'd be fooling themselves if they thought the extra ability of the CSL is anything but wasted on public roads. Then you might as well buy any other BMW, with some small amount of the usual creature comforts.

Maybe that way the "true enthusiasts" would be left with more supply, and not because other people bought the car for its rarity and not to enjoy its abilities.
 

BMW M

BMW M GmbH, formerly known as BMW Motorsport GmbH, is a subsidiary of BMW AG that manufactures high-performance luxury cars. BMW M ("M" for "motorsport") was initially created to facilitate BMW's racing program, which was very successful in the 1960s and 1970s. As time passed, BMW M began to supplement BMW's vehicle portfolio with specially modified higher trim models, for which they are now most known by the general public. These M-badged cars traditionally include modified engines, transmissions, suspensions, interior trims, aerodynamics, and exterior modifications to set them apart from their counterparts. All M models are tested and tuned at BMW's private facility at the Nürburgring racing circuit in Germany.
Official website: BMW M

Trending content


Back
Top