- Messages
- 11,171
I think Pfeiffer was still chief at this time? I wonder which is the first MB where Gordon would be the head honcho? Anyone know?
I think Pfeiffer was still chief at this time? I wonder which is the first MB where Gordon would be the head honcho? Anyone know?
Chief of exterior design deserves to be raped by monkeys.
He probably was, yet on the other hand, he left in '08 right? Which means that this thing was probably still in development, or probably finishing development right around when he left. Remember, some article said that the A-Class was Wageners first design as Head, so maybe this is as well.
Personally, I think Pfeiffer was masterful. I feel like all these overly-ambitious design messes are credit to Wagener, as it's clear that's his direction and his personality fits that. I like his work of course, but I feel that he's the type that needs to be Managed, or else he'll go crazy with weird stuff like what we're seeing on current M-B's. Basically, it is my "hunch" that the funky elements we see on even Benzes developed under Pfeiffers watch, were highly influenced by Wagener, however, they were possibly able to be balanced.
The lines on the CLS pushed it for me, but I can somewhat accept them (though I don't like them). They needed to be done for individuality, however, IMO they sacrificed pure Design harmony for the sake of differentiation. The lines on the A and B are just detestable, not right on a Hyundai, much less a Benz.
He probably was, yet on the other hand, he left in '08 right? Which means that this thing was probably still in development, or probably finishing development right around when he left. Remember, some article said that the A-Class was Wageners first design as Head, so maybe this is as well.
Personally, I think Pfeiffer was masterful. I feel like all these overly-ambitious design messes are credit to Wagener, as it's clear that's his direction and his personality fits that. I like his work of course, but I feel that he's the type that needs to be Managed, or else he'll go crazy with weird stuff like what we're seeing on current M-B's. Basically, it is my "hunch" that the funky elements we see on even Benzes developed under Pfeiffers watch, were highly influenced by Wagener, however, they were possibly able to be balanced.
The lines on the CLS pushed it for me, but I can somewhat accept them (though I don't like them). They needed to be done for individuality, however, IMO they sacrificed pure Design harmony for the sake of differentiation. The lines on the A and B are just detestable, not right on a Hyundai, much less a Benz.

I don't know KA. Wagoner has said Future MB's are going to be cleaner and more proportion driven, so it's really very difficult to tell who was behind these lines. They don't work here. But they do on the A concept and CLS.
^![]()
Mercedes has not revealed who designed the new B. In the meantime, we have concept A to go with, which shares some of the features:
![]()
it's easily as good and anything Audi has done.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.