Vs AutoZeitung: BMW 118d vs Toyota Prius

[KokkenTor]

AutoZeitung have tested two models with low CO2 emmissions, BMW 118d vs Toyota Prius. Results from the test:

Model ………….......…… 118d …… Prius
Karosserie ….....….…… 590 …….. 529
Comfort ………......……. 647 ……… 603
Engine/gear ........... 678 …… 585
Driving Dynamics .….. 650 ……… 467
Cost/environment ..... 448 ……… 481
Total ……………......….. 3 013 ….. 2 665

Weight (kg) ………….. 1 374 ……. 1 300
Consumtion .….….… … 5,9 ….. …. 5,9
Lap time ……....…….. 1:54,2 .… 2:05,1
Slalom (km/h)………… 63,5 …….. 59,4
0-100km/h .............. 9,1 ....... 12,0
80-120km/h ............ 6,8 ....... 11,1
Hp/Nm ............... 143/300 .. 78/115 (E-motor: 68/400)
Price (€) ............... 25 300 .. 24 877

The BMW wins with a huge margin:
1. BMW 118d - 3 013 points
2. Toyota Prius - 2 665 points

 

[Tarek]

Poor Toyota

 

[bmer]

Toyota vs. BMW, not very fair I'd say.

 

[cawimmer430]

The Prius got higher marks for environment (as expected), but the BMW 118d wasn't so far off in terms of emissions (even though we're comparing diesel to gasoline here). Modern catalytic converters, particulate filters and even engine design (combustion process etc.) all help keep emissions low, even on a diesel like the 118d.

Give me the 118d anyday.

 

[Centurion]

Toyota Prius comes most likely to use in cities with heavy congestion like in to and from LA, when you end up cruising at very low speed during rush hour. Meaning that the car will run a great amount on its electric engine.

 

[wltsm]

Interesting comparison, but I'd get the 118d anyday, it's more of a normal car, has much better performance and you get a BMW!

 

[Cashmere]

Interesting comparison, but I'd get the 118d anyday, it's more of a normal car, has much better performance and you get a BMW!

The Prius tho is still definitely more practical...

 

[cawimmer430]

The Prius tho is still definitely more practical...

Only in the city if you're a tree-hugger.

 

[Cashmere]

Only in the city if you're a tree-hugger.

Actually I was thinking more in the sense of a back seat orgy...prius back seats can easily work as a sofa.....the 1 series is a bit of a 'tight squeeze'