Audi Shooting-Brake Concept or BMW Z4 Coupé Concept?


Audi Shooting-brake vs. Z4 Coupé

  • Audi Shooting-brake Concept

    Votes: 22 33.3%
  • BMW Z4 Coupé Concept

    Votes: 44 66.7%

  • Total voters
    66
For me, it's the Z4 Coupe Concept.

The Audi Shooting-Brake looks quite nice actually...if you're standing from the rear-3/4 view. I really like the side profile and the rear-end especially, ..but it's the front which really makes me say "ohh darn it, this car was looking so good till I had to see the front!".
As stated by others, the front is pretty much Ford Focus lights,..in other words it's rather unimaginative, especially considering this is a concept car.
The front grille with the vertical bars reminds me of Hannibal Lector's face-mask, so that's a definate thumbs down in my books.
Other than those 2 aspects, the rest of the car is quite nice indeed,..even the interior is well done.

The Z4 Coupe Concept on the other hand has no real flaws in terms of design (in my eyes that is).
The Z4 itself is a car I very much like, ...so much so that I had a difficult time deciding which was my favourite looking new BMW (until the M5 came out ofcourse). So yes, it's safe to assume that I really like the Z4's looks, ....except for one aspect, that being the rear end, .... and that's where the Z4 Coupe' Concept scores bonus points over the regular Z4.
The regular Z4's rear lights were a bit toy-ish/cartoon-ish in their looks, especially with the round white section inside the red light which highly contrasted with the sharp lines of the rest of the car. Same thing with the bootlid, which had that curvy shape. I always hoped that it would have a strong rear end, with a solid horizontal bootlid much like the 7er and 6er, ..but it ended up being curvy. The Z4 Coupe' Concept fixes that issue for me very well by having the true BMW butt.

Since we are comparing these 2 concepts, the BMW also wins in terms of the interior, ...mainly due to the fact that extra attention has been paid to it because the car is a concept.

...and finally, the wheel design of the Z4 Coupe' Concept. After seeing the first pictures of the car just as it was unveiled at the Frankfurt Motorshow, the wheels instantly caught my attention, ...and my reaction was "OMG, .... they've been possessed by the devil!!"....it even has the trident look to it.

So to sum up all this mumbo-jumbo, ... Z4 Coupe' Concept gets my vote, firstly due to the fact that it improves of my design dislikes on the regular Z4,..and secondly due to Audi's poor execution of the front-end of the TT Shooting-Brake.

(Disclaimer: All statements made in this post are purely IMO!!) :usa7uh:
 
I voted for the Audi, not because its so nice. I dont like it that much, but it looks better than the BMW. I think BMW is doing well with their design but this is simply ugly! :pukeface: The Z4 needs a facelift like the 7er.
The 7er was really ( I mean "REALY") ugly and now its handsome :usa7uh:
But the Z4 is realy ( and I mean "REALY") ugly and its still............



Oww I forgot, IMO
 
Kleemann_SL said:
The Z4 needs a facelift like the 7er.
The 7er was really ( I mean "REALY") ugly and now its handsome :usa7uh:
But the Z4 is realy ( and I mean "REALY") ugly and its still............
Oww I forgot, IMO

I co-sign that!
 
Audiholic said:
I co-sign that!

I dont ;)
I never liked the old TT, made me puke :pukeface: the new one looks better but its to early to say I like it. There are probably going to be some minor changes. I want to see the final product before I decide my mind so for now, BMW Z4 Coupé :usa7uh:
 
Kleemann_SL said:
I voted for the Audi, not because its so nice. I dont like it that much, but it looks better than the BMW. I think BMW is doing well with their design but this is simply ugly! :pukeface: The Z4 needs a facelift like the 7er.
The 7er was really ( I mean "REALY") ugly and now its handsome :usa7uh:
But the Z4 is realy ( and I mean "REALY") ugly and its still............

No facelift or minor change can improve the Z4. Let's only hope that the next Z4 will be better (in 3-4 years from now).
 
BMW.... I like this coupe a lot better than the regular Z4. Although I'll say that this isn't like my favorite BMW or anything.

That Audi concept on the other hand has not grown on me, not even a little bit. Everything looks ok until you see the front face on. Like Beemer boi said, the lights are generic and that grill has got to go.

However, the car did look much better when someone PSed the grill
 
You know what the difference between these concepts is? TT will look even better in coupe and roadster production versions while Z4 coupe will look the same.


 
Yannis said:
You know what the difference between these concepts is? TT will look even better in coupe and roadster production versions while Z4 coupe will look the same.

I dont understand :confused:
 
Just_me said:
I dont understand :confused:

The TT Shooting brake wil not be the only version of TT. There will also be a coupe and roadster version like the PS above and those look much better.
 
Yannis said:
The TT Shooting brake wil not be the only version of TT. There will also be a coupe and roadster version like the PS above and those look much better.

Just like Z4 roadster and Z4 Coupé.
And the design part - as always - design is matter of personal preferences. No rights or wrong here.
 
Z4 coupe has more votes so far. I guess we have many BMW fans around here. :D
 
Yannis said:
Z4 coupe has more votes so far. I guess we have many BMW fans around here. :D

These polls mean nothing since we arent the majority. However I find the Z4 C attractive, much more than the Roadster. :usa7uh:
 
I just voted for the BMW... :eek2:

There are still many things I don't like about the Z4, but the coupé's overall shape is a million time better than the roadster's. Even that weird dent-thingy ("flame surfacing" I suppose) on the side somehow seems to work better on the coupé. The non-gloss silver paint is great, lately BMW has been painting its show cars in the oddest hues but this time they've really gotten it right.

The TT then... I've never liked the current TT and if the new one will look anything like the PS's Yannis posted I will not like it either. Maybe I will dislike it a bit less but that's it. I just don't like the shape of the thing. The Shooting Brake does indeed look like a regular hatchback and in my eyes the rear is more Seat than Audi.
 
Yeah, I agree that polls are uselles, it only matters who has the most fans.
But I still like the Z4 roadster and coupe. Underneath that futuristic flame surfaced car I see the 328 Mille Miglias.
Witch is great IMO. :usa7uh:
 
I like the Z4 coupe a lot. To me it mixtures classic style with new style. But I really like the Audi and if I had to pick I would probably pick the Audi, but then again I would be split over the Z4. I voted for the Z4 because it is what I would like to have, but the Audi is something that I can't deny is a beautiful piece of art.
 
I picked the Z4 only because the front grill on the Audi is horrendous looking and unacceptable aesthetically. If the front looked good, the rest of the car is sweet and would have picked it easily over the Z4 which at some angles has weird proportions. The Cayman looks funny at angles too since the cockpit makes a sort of bubble shape.
 
Back
Top