Which one do you choose between the two sisters? More twins than ever before

[dalab]

 

[J.E]

BMW X1 with xDrive.

 

[martinbo]

Great poll. Tough decision but the X1 for me has styling that's spot on.

 

[Centurion]

Mini. The X1 has a fresh design language but the lights, rear especially, are a bit caricature-esque.

 

[Gor134]

X1, one of the few good looking new BMW designs. But ideally, wouldn't choose either.

 

[martinbo]

X1, one of the few good looking new BMW designs. But ideally, wouldn't choose either.

In this class, though, there isn’t much else to choose. GLB is hideous, overpriced and cheap inside; Q3 is old hat; Tonale - well, Alfa… and Evoque ownership comes with a risk advisory.

 

[Giannis]

Great poll, indeed!

I'd go for the MINI. Since we're talking high-seating-position FWD cars with room for 5, I'd go for the hottest design. The new Countryman has blown me away!

 

[dalab]

Great poll, indeed!

I'd go for the MINI. Since we're talking high-seating-position FWD cars with room for 5, I'd go for the hottest design. The new Countryman has blown me away!

Also maybe a little more exclusive (as strange as that may sound)