Sport Auto: Comparsions

[CarGuy]

Karma for all your work......thanks
u and zafiro , work hardest here

 

[CarGuy]

Can u do C6 vs. SRT-10.
I don't understand why the Viper is so slow on the track.
So i take it the SL65 performs better thn the S65 or CL65?

 

[Bruce]

Can u do C6 vs. SRT-10.
I don't understand why the Viper is so slow on the track.

But before i do it, i want to ask a question. The SRT-10 that was run in the supertest was an imported Viper with modifications and that run 1:14.xx on the Hockenheim, however Sport Auto got their hands ont he real European SRT-10 last year and it was clearly a better car. So i can use the Hockenheim, braking and acceleration figures for the European SRT-10 and then use the Nurburgring times for the Imported SRT-10. It's up to you, or i can leave the Nurburgring out and as well as a few other numbers from the test (36 Metre slalom & etc) and just compare the C6 and the European SRT-10 simply on the Hockenheim, the 18 metre slalom

What would you want?


EDIT: The SL65 is more sporty than the CL and S

Hope it makes sense

 

[CarGuy]

Combine the 2 different cars to include all the data. But if it takes to long I feel to bad just forget it. You do way more than the average member here.

 

[Bruce]

Combine the 2 different cars to include all the data. But if it takes to long I feel to bad just forget it. You do way more than the average member here.

Pretty much everything i post takes a long time So i'm a very patient guy

SRT-10 vs C6 coming up!

 

[Bruce]

*Please note, the SRT-10 used for these particular tests is the imported SRT-10:

-36 Metre Slalom
-110 Metre Evasive
-200km/h-0 in seconds
-Complete Nurburgring data

Ending score:

SRT-10: 44 points
C6: 40 points

http://img183.imageshack.us/my.php?image=musclesportsei4.jpg

 

[CarGuy]

Id rather have a C6 than an SRT-10 or Gallardo.
Plus the C6 is more practical than the ZO6 so I win.
The C6 is faster than a C5 ZO6, and gets same laptimes around tracks.

 

[Matt]

Id take teh Gallardo. God it such a good looking car that even though a Z06 outguns it, it just looks so much better. Its a great track car as well, sure not the best but very good and great for begginners because of AWD.

 

[Bruce]

Decided to do a new comparsion today, in light of the data i've obtained for the 04 GT2 Sport Auto test. It struck me as an interesting comparsion, both vehicles are capable of 0-200 km/h in about 12 seconds, both weight about the same and lastly both have a Hockenheim time of under 1:12 (1:11.5 for the C6 and 1:11.6 for the GT2)

So then it's:

VS

Overall score ends up: 41 for the Porsche, 18 for the Z06. The braking times and the track times are extremely close, but the GT2 claws the lead with better in-time acceleration:

http://img55.imageshack.us/my.php?image=twoscdj2.jpg

This is also got me thinking, the GT2's time of 1:11.6 is less than a second away from the Zonda F's lap time (1:10.8). So, can the Zonda F battle off a GT2?

Zonda scores 42, GT2 scores 18 (this is of course excluding the 'Ring and a number of other categories (36metre, 110m evasive) because the 04 GT2 never got tested in a supertest

http://img58.imageshack.us/my.php?image=pvpcr5.jpg




I'll also be creating the Cayman S vs Boxster S comparsion soon

 

[Zafiro]

when 997TT will be tested around nordschleife I want to see Z06 vs 997TT from you

 

[Bruce]

when 997TT will be tested around nordschleife I want to see Z06 vs 997TT from you

I want to see it too And i'll make sure to make it when they get tested!

 

[Bruce]

Just made a new one for my personal interest:

Koenigsegg CCR vs Porsche Carrera GT vs Pagani Zonda F








All three cars prove to be extremely good sports cars, with all finishing with near identical scores:

Carrera GT: 30 Points
Zonda F: 29 Points
CCR: 25 Points

I'll add the LP640 when it's supertest comes, but in all honestly i don't think it'll gather much points

 

[CarGuy]

Like always the CGT and Zonda tight as it can get, best 3 supercars of 2006 no dought, 2bad we have the CGT done.

 

[Bruce]

Like always the CGT and Zonda tight as it can get, best 3 supercars of 2006 no dought, 2bad we have the CGT done.

Yeah it's a shame it isn't in production anymore, because i was going to buy one next week...

Anyways, they got a large run off the Carrera GT, 1270 units to be exact and i guess that's all they needed. I know some people think the Carrera GT's production figures were a little too high, but i can't say it ever bothered me that much. I suppose, ideally i would have gone for 600 total. Either way Porsche has made lots of money off the vehicle and it was a smart move to make it

 

[Bruce]

I made a new comparsion: Jaguar XKR vs Maserati GranSport

Btw i'm some what bored right now, so if anybody wants to request a comparsion between two vehicle (three if you want) i'll happily make it

[/URL]

 

[Mr. M]

I made a new comparsion: Jaguar XKR vs Maserati GranSport

Btw i'm some what bored right now, so if anybody wants to request a comparsion between two vehicle (three if you want) i'll happily make it

[/URL]

Wow, ownage by Gransport! Just look at those acceleration figures!

 

[Bruce]

Wow, ownage by Gransport! Just look at those acceleration figures!

Yeah, the in-time acceleration figures of the GranSport stomp the XKR and not just the XKR, it holds up pretty damn well against the 997 Carrera S too

Any comparsions you'd like to see in particular Mirage? (or anybody)

I can pit the GranSport against the 997 Carrera S if you like, or i can go 997S vs V8 Vantage vs GranSport. Or maybe something completley different?

 

[Mr. M]

Yeah, the in-time acceleration figures of the GranSport stomp the XKR and not just the XKR, it holds up pretty damn well against the 997 Carrera S too

Any comparsions you'd like to see in particular Mirage? (or anybody)

I can pit the GranSport against the 997 Carrera S if you like, or i can go 997S vs V8 Vantage vs GranSport. Or maybe something completley different?

I feel very bad for asking Bruce. It'll really take up so much of your time!

But since you asked... I'd love to see one comparing all the sports saloons, the S63AMG, S8, Quattroporte Sport GT and the Jaguar XJ Super V8... Did I miss out any car?

It'll be fantastic, I'll owe you 1000 karma. But if it takes up too much of your time, I don't mind you not doing it at all.

 

[Bruce]

I feel very bad for asking Bruce. It'll really take up so much of your time!

But since you asked... I'd love to see one comparing all the sports saloons, the S63AMG, S8, Quattroporte Sport GT and the Jaguar XJ Super V8... Did I miss out any car?

It'll be fantastic, I'll owe you 1000 karma. But if it takes up too much of your time, I don't mind you not doing it at all.

Don't feel bad for asking, i enjoy doing this stuff. Unfortantley and ironically i don't have any supertests for any of those vehicles ..Because they've never been tested.

I'm afraid i do not have many practical vehicles because when doing super tests Sport Auto leans towards sports car



Multiple tests from one maker:

-Pagani Zonda F
-Pagani Zonda S

-Mercedes-Benz SLK55 AMG
-Mercedes-Benz CLK DTM
-Mercedes-Benz C55 AMG
-Mercedes-Benz SLR McLaren
-Mercedes-Benz SL65 AMG

-Porsche 997 GT3
-Porsche 996 GT3
-Porsche 996 GT3RS
-Porsche Cayman S
-Porsche 987 Boxster S
-Porsche 997 Carrera S


-BMW Z4 3.0CSi
-BMW M3 CSL
-BMW E60 M5
-BMW 335i
-BMW M6

-Audi RS4 MK1 Avant
-Audi B7 RS4

-Aston Martin DB9
-Aston Martin V8 Vantage

-Ferrari F430
-Ferrari 360 Challenge Stradale
-575M Maranello
-550 Maranello

-Individual Super Tests


-Lamborghini Gallardo
-Maserati GranSport
-AC Schnitzer V8 Topster
-Jaguar XKR,2007
-Dodge Viper SRT-10
-Koenigsegg CCR
-Ford GT
-Volkswagen R32 MK2
-Chevrolet Corvette C6
-Alpina Roadster S

Small test

However if i go for small Sport Auto tests (which includes the Hockenheim, but no 'Ring, 36 metre slalom, 110 metre evasive and etc) i've got these and can compare any of these. I could also get a test from above and compare it to the below, but again i would have to take away the Ring time and a few other tests. It's up to you.




-BMW 545i
-BMW 650Ci Cabriolet
-BMW 530i
-BMW 645Ci Cabriolet
-BMW 130i

-Mercedes-Benz CLK63 AMG
-Mercedes-Benz SL500, 2006 (388PS)
-Mercedes-Benz CLS55 AMG
-Mercedes-Benz SL55 AMG (517PS)
-Mercedes-Benz SLK55 Black Series (built by SA)
-Mercedes-Benz E55 AMG

-Audi TT 3.2 Quattro 07
-Audi S3, 2007
-Audi S6 V10

-Porsche 997 Turbo
-Porsche 997 Carrera 4S Cabriolet
-Porsche 996 GT2, 2004 (483PS)
-Porsche Cayman S

-Lamborghini Gallardo Spyder
-Lamborghini Gallaro SE

-Jaguar XK 4.2, 2007

-Alfa Romeo Brera Q4 V6
-Alpina B5
-Chevrolet Corvette C6 Z06
-Donkervoort D8 RS06
-MTM Bentley Continental GT
-TVR Tuscan MK2
-Gemballa GT550
-Mini Cooper Works GP Package
-Aston Martin DB9 Volante
-Dodge Viper SRT-10 (Euro)
-Lotus Europa
-Renaultsport Clio 197

 

[Mr. M]

Don't feel bad for asking, i enjoy doing this stuff. Unfortantley and ironically i don't have any supertests for any of those vehicles ..Because they've never been tested.

I'm afraid i do not have many practical's vehicles because when doing super tests Sport Auto leans towards sports car

'Practical cars'.

Don't worry about it then Bruce, I don't need any other test. Thanks for offering.