He was a very iconic car designer for me, I think most of his designs especially 70's and 80's were so timeless and elegant and also the late 90's to early 2000 designed cars were very sleek as well. His worst era for me is the early 1990's to late 1990's, I am not a big fan of the W140 S-class, the first C-Class, the first ML-Class and especially not a fan at all of the twin light W210 E-Class, which lacked the elegance and sheer presence of the W124 and also it was poorly engineered especially interior design and quality and electronics, which severely dented Merc's image as "built like a bank safe" and its slogan "engineered like no other car in the world" by breaking down/falling apart and cost the company millions. Cars I liked from the 1990's are the first A-Class (mostly cause of its clever design and engineering), the first SLK, the W220 S-Class as well as CL-class.
Well to be honest, while he was head of design, he wasn't entirely responsible for initial design themselves. He was definitely responsible for the final production model after the design release. Most the cost-cutting changes were authorized in 1991 by McKinsey & Company. A hired consulting firm that sought to reduce 10-15% in Daimler-Benz' overhead costs by 1995, to better compete with Lexus and Acura (Legend) regarding pricing. That same year, Steve Mattin's W210 design was mostly defined and later finalized in early 1992, based on these new principles. The W202, had been finalized around January 1990 and in development since late 1986, became affected by these decisions as well via the production process in 1993 (outsourcing).
The W210, R170 were more of a mid-point in MBs design transition from boxy outline with rounded edges to rounded contours (W168, W220). The W140 on another note, had a height adjustment of its roof by 4 inches in 1987, several months after reaching the final design in December 1986. They tried to rapidly correct this in 1992, while developing a "less bulky W140" for the 1994 facelift. They succeeded in early 1995 with the sleeker, monotone-only appearance that arrived for the '97 model year refresh.
This is what Bruno Sacco once said, likely in reference to the W210 and W220: “The aesthetics of a product can never hope to make up for poor-quality technology.”
Yep, the R170. I was going to go with that, but felt the four-eyed look was a very important turn for Mercedes-Benz. It seems MB made the shift towards this theme in 1992, judging by early sketches of the W220 S-Class from October 1992.Thanks for this great historical write up explaining the cost cutting and relation to design/production dates etc. for the various 90's Mercs, I found this very interesting. The transition model from boxy/rounded edges to the rounded contours was the R170 SLK as this highlighted many design aspects such as the tail light and headlight design that found their way onto other models released from 1998 to early 2000's.
Actually, it's both. A few random guys I been able to converse with, as well as internet research over the past 4 years, MB history books, and subscription access material. No thanks to Google Archive Search being disabled lately, that I've lost a ton of my original sources from archives. I found out that the W163 began initial development in 1990 as a W463 Gelandewagen replacement in a 1991 article and partnered with Mitsubishi (cancelled, independently from 1992). I previously used a lot of this research on university projects.Facinating information @Carmaker1. Have your read this stuff in a book somewhere, or is it more a collation of information you have read over time?
If it's from a book, I'd love to have a read of it. The happenings within MB design and engineering really interest me.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.