Zafiro
Supreme Roadmaster
- Messages
- 30,811
It's just my opinion though.
![]()
exactly
I've driven many petrol and diesel cars. A diesel engine cant replace a real petrol engine even if its a R8 diesel engine or a BMW M3 diesel engine.

It's just my opinion though.
![]()

A M3 powered by a diesel engine would be blasphemy.exactly
I've driven many petrol and diesel cars. A diesel engine cant replace a real petrol engine even if its a R8 diesel engine or a BMW M3 diesel engine.![]()

IMO, the engine in the R8 will sound diesel. I've driven for instance the 400cdi when it was released, and it sounded awfully diesel, my bro has a 30d and it is 100% diesel with no real reving, and the peak power in the middle of the rev-counter, then it decreases... The 320cdi is fabulous, because it is very well damped and you almost hear nothing.Well, if this car ever goes into producion, it will definitely not sound like a A4 TDI or any diesel powered vehicle!
As for the performance of the car, I don't believe it's going to be less exciting to drive than its gasoline rivals. With a 1000Nm of torque and a advanced Quattro system, it would be very quick on the N-ring. It's just my opinion though.
![]()

Hate to ruin your dreams guys but there will be no R8 V12. The V12 diesel engine is apparently too big and heavy to fit in the R8.
Read here for more details...
Fourtitude Forums: Ripples of R8 TDI for Detroit Are Everywhere. But, Are They True?
On the other hand a R8 V10 Twin Turbo (RS6 engine) is very possible.

Couldn't agree more with you about the benefits of a high reving V8 engine that runs on petrol but still, you can't really tell if a diesel powered high performance car would be total nonsense until you see one proving the opposite.IMO, the engine in the R8 will sound diesel. I've driven for instance the 400cdi when it was released, and it sounded awfully diesel, my bro has a 30d and it is 100% diesel with no real reving, and the peak power in the middle of the rev-counter, then it decreases... The 320cdi is fabulous, because it is very well damped and you almost hear nothing.
Modern diesels are fabulous: powerful, not so noisy any more, very torquey, very economical. Perfect on an E-Class or BMW 5er.
But they can't rev, they have no real redzone and if you rev them too long you loose power, and the noise is crappy.
So they lack the sportiness, imo. They are fast, powerful, no doubt. But not really sporty.
Nothing replaces the noise of a petrol, the power always increasing with the revving and ending in a thrilling, metallic sound when you hit the redzone... Or, in a different way, the terrific thunder of a big V8 angrily pushing you always further in a cataclysmic borborygm.
This is what an R8 (and any sportcat) is about. This what an diesel can't offer.
A diesel is...a bit emotionless. It does its work perfectly, often better than a petrol one. But the petrol engine has so much more soul, with its sound and reving power, it is just more sporty.
I love the word of W. Wiedeking, Porsche 's CEO:
"Pleasure begins at 4.000rpm. This is where a diesel ends."
Of course, to each its own, this is just my thinking about diesel!
![]()

And yet BMW's relatively mass-produced inline-6 twin turbo reaches peak hp 400 rpm beyond this, and redlines at 5000 rpm.I love the word of W. Wiedeking, Porsche 's CEO:
"Pleasure begins at 4.000rpm. This is where a diesel ends."
Which is precisely why, were they to build it, Audi would specify a different kind of engine. Do you honestly think they'd put nothing more special than a 635d motor into their supercar? You do want something else than for a 635d and, knowing Audi, you can get it. After all, this is the company that has turned world expectation on its head at least twice in only a few short years.But for a supercar you want something else than for a 635d...
Not all of the reviews for the R8 say that. If you look at the Car, Car & Driver, Autocar, etc. reviews, the sound is often mentioned only in passing or sometimes not at all. It is by no means a defining nature of the R8. Evo in at least two reviews has failed to even mention the R8's high-rpm sound. Others mention the sound when bringing up one of the car's few shortcomings. Car Magazine said:All reviews about big petrol are saying that the noise is fabulous, incredible, threatening, thundering...
...
I say what my Croatian bro says.Bring it on!![]()

We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.