Jeremy Clarkson reviews the Mercedes-Benz E500 Sport and oh dear...

[HighestOfHigh]

Again, some people's opinions are worth more than others.

Again, that's the whole point, he's talking about cars - the emotion, joy and passion behind them. It's not a physics lecture in thermodynamic efficiency. All discussion beyond the pure science of motoring takes place at an emotional, subjective level.

Well here is the thing..If you take someone who has driven a certain car and someone who hasn't, then yes their opinion would matter more. On the other hand, if I were looking for information on the new E-class and interested in how it drives, I would look at a wide range of Journalist thoughts on the new car. No way No how would I consider his opinion to be more substantial then say a Journalist from Automobile Magazine.

One thing that people have to realize is that people have different taste. Let say dr Dunkel vs me. He loves the mini cooper and I believe he actually owns one. On the other hand I don't like the mini cooper. Why should someone on this forum who is interested in the mini cooper value my opinion over dr Dunkel? It should matter whether they like me better or think my opinion is the best. If anything they should listen to dr Dunkel and my opinion, then go drive the car themselves.

I understand that Clarkson may have millions of followers who probably even go buy cars based on his opinion. I am just saying that in my opinion his views are worthless to me, when considering a car. What matters to me about a car is dependability, looks, pricing, equipment and power. Clarkson and his little unecessary jokes don't appeal to me in the least bit.

As far as his piece on the E-class it just seems as though he didn't like one thing, which made him extend that disappointment to the rest of the car. Up to a certain part I can agree with him. I am not the greatest fan of the e-class when it comes to the rear, but I highly doubt that the Benz lacks in any other department. Then again like someone said he loved the S-class not to mention that the wheel arches are there based on previous models of the past, yet it didn't moan and groan then.

I guess my problem is I don't like people to play games. Drive the car and tell me about it. I don't need you to moan and groan about a small design issue throughout half the article. Get to the point...that's all I ask for.

As much as I hated the 5 series for the bucktooth grill and messed up lights, once I drove it I actually liked it. I didn't let my dislike for Bangles design affect my judgement. In the end it is always going to come down to what I like, not what Clarkson likes. I really hope that people decided on their cars that way as well.

But...if you think he is the best there is, then so be it. I am happy for you.

 

[ALI]

If he couldn't turn it off, it's on purpose and to highlight the complexity of the car.
Clarkson may be funny, may have excessive opinions. But if you take what he says with a pinch of salt, you realize he's mostly right about the essence of the car he testdrove.

I'm sorry, but for me he IS brilliant. I don't take him too seriously, because that's the way he works, but on the bottom line he's quite spot one....

The Idrive in the M5 is not that complex, he is known for HIS EXADURATING for the sake of being funny, his first glance at a car 100% of the time affects his whole review, now i call that being ignorant and 'OLD', thats how old people get, no ofense!!

 

[HighestOfHigh]

his first glance at a car 100% of the time affects his whole review, now i call that being ignorant and 'OLD', thats how old people get, no ofense!!

You speak the truth!

 

[CarGuy]

If I knew 10% of 10% of what Clarkson knows about cars, I'd be a happy happy man.

Martin I can't believe a person like you and what I expect from you, would defend this idiot and not only that you put yourself down with a statement like this!

Although he does sometimes write witty articles.

PS: Clarkson is still useless.

 

[NarutoRamen]

Martin, my friend, you might as well stop trying to defend him. There is nothing that anyone can say that will change people's minds. Just know that you are not alone in your views, it's just that it's a waste of time to argue on the internet with stubborn people on both sides.

 

[CarGuy]

^OMG u just called me an idiot and you think your so clever and witty that I would have missed that!

Well I debunked your conspiracy and I know for a fact that what you wrote up there was an inside job!

PS: Don't be hatin bro!

 

[Centurion]

Top Gear has a purpose, but so has Evo and even the layman's auto magazines. If you take every word that comes out of Clarkson's mouth literary then it's your problem. The shows value lay in delivering automotive news in chewable chunks for the general public who might not even know the basic physical difference between a V6 and an in-line 6.

I have my fair share of preferable publications like Wall Street Journal and other highly reputable media outlets, but occasionally I enjoy picking up a semi-gossip paper just for the sake of winding down after a long day by reading some soft and funny words -- And that's exactly what Clarkson does, he makes people laugh and smile for a living. What he writes and says probably don't represent his interest as a car enthusiast. All that said on the show is scripted and planned to make people have an enjoyable 60 minutes at 20:00 every Sunday. It's a family program that can be watched by the highest octane petrol head to those who have never even driven a car in their entire life. I follow Top Gear and take from it what I want and for the rest that I don't get, there is Car & Driver and Drivers-republic. Life is no simpler than that.

 

[NarutoRamen]

^OMG u just called me an idiot and you think your so clever and witty that I would have missed that!

Well I debunked your conspiracy and I know for a fact that what you wrote up there was an inside job!

PS: Don't be hatin bro!

What? I said or done no such thing good sir.

 

[CarGuy]

All right, my bad then.

Ignore my silly comment.

 

[martinbo]

For the record; do I agree with everything Clarkson says? Of course not. I have the ability to form my own opinions based on my own experience and knowledge.

Does that change my view on his brilliance as a human being for "living the automotive dream"? Not at all. To get all of what he does done, I understand that he works very very hard. And this is one of the reasons I admire him.

Where some people might think Clarkson is admirable, by the same token, others will think he isn't - and that is perfectly fair.

Just don't judge him for a fool. He's far from that.

But, HoH and the others you make good points.

 

[HighestOfHigh]

Just don't judge him for a fool. He's far from that.

But, HoH and the others you make good points.

Lol..You know what happen is Mercedes-Benz fans saw him just rip the E-class and after that...something just clicked and we went on attack mode. It is amazing how loyal some of us are to Mercedes-Benz.

I still don't like Clarkson or his style of writing, but I will try not to call him an idiot.

 

[Jabba]

I have a big advantage... its the first time i read the name Jeremy Clarkson, believe it or not!

So i had the chance to read his article without any predjudice, did not know what is waiting for me.
I was very surprised reading this from an author who is obiously only interrested to find something negativ, trying to make everthing ridiculous and covering it with some silly jokes and even more stupid comparisons that nobody would expect to read in a car review.

As a pro, you should be able to do your job with a neutral point of view. After the job is done, you may tell your personal opinion and feelings, wether you like the car for some reasons or not.

For me it appears, that someone who absolutely dislikes the new E Class was forced to write a review and he just hates his job...
=> My personal conclusion: If i see the Name J.C. i will turn over to the next page...

 

[ALI]

For the record; do I agree with everything Clarkson says? Of course not. I have the ability to form my own opinions based on my own experience and knowledge.

Does that change my view on his brilliance as a human being for "living the automotive dream"? Not at all. To get all of what he does done, I understand that he works very very hard. And this is one of the reasons I admire him.

Where some people might think Clarkson is admirable, by the same token, others will think he isn't - and that is perfectly fair.

Just don't judge him for a fool. He's far from that.

But, HoH and the others you make good points.

Exactly Martinbo, couldnt have said it any better, our own experiences are all that matter, and from there it's up to us to adjust, and when we do, some may agree and some may disagree, and the world goes round .

Originally posted by HighestOfHigh
Lol..You know what happen is Mercedes-Benz fans saw him just rip the E-class and after that...something just clicked and we went on attack mode. It is amazing how loyal some of us are to Mercedes-Benz.

I still don't like Clarkson or his style of writing, but I will try not to call him an idiot.

I just highlighted on previous impressions by him, which are impressions that I do not admire, I admit he is funny, he makes me laugh, but thats all ..

 

[coolraoul]

=> My personal conclusion: If i see the Name J.C. i will turn over to the next page...

Don't!
While all of his reviews are not equal, and this one certainly isn't one of his best, he actually wrote some reviews so funny you couldn't help but pee on yourself. While always saying smthg very true, behind the excessiveness and jokes and silly comparisons (which are his specialty).

When I see the name Jeremy Clarkson, I know I won't necessarily learn smthg about the car, but i know I will laugh a lot, and often will have smthg to think about once the laughing is over.

Now you want some advice? Go on Youtube, type in "Top Gear" and see the most funny automobile broadcast ever.

 

[Mr. Mercedes]

LOL...Funny thread.

 

[HighestOfHigh]

I just highlighted on previous impressions by him, which are impressions that I do not admire, I admit he is funny, he makes me laugh, but thats all ..

Other then his articles posted on this website, I don't even watch his shows or bother to read his articles on other sites. Just not interested. But if Clarkson makes you laugh, then I am happy for you.

One of the most decent Automotive programs I have seen is MotorWeek. They are straight to the point, not time for pointless jokes. I have no time to sit around and giggle about a car. Tell me the facts and get off the air.

Sorry that's just the way I feel...