Car and Driver - 09' Porsche Boxster S vs. BMW Z4 sDrive35i, Audi TTS, Chevy Corvette


Merc1

Premium
cd681efa217873637a99ae0e18dd3b62.webp


f971dca3582b0447ae6b9fbd07fab679.webp


098285c7d415067a6d1b0645246bc7b0.webp


9d68fe27d1695e233ee847da82dd384a.webp


2a13cc382579d8112c1c1f29ec0f2d6b.webp


af724d9484392af8a45918b9d89bc527.webp


962e08efbdf18bb8deee6a4e351a5583.webp


f7ea8e67797c5e0e4cb5362276217a64.webp


843584811cf78d53509868b4ef23c246.webp


671e4aca28e6965db8ce2d9dac34443c.webp


17109a3b2c490e3b30dc984feea7f7c4.webp


530f7a7d287ed2986d642cb16115f3e0.webp


e2e28690774702d2e10c56d3cf083cf9.webp


020fe02fccc59204579c5ac125aec371.webp


5182506a8080104966df3b30cbc394c6.webp


b9f5aa49bb24d05b98f03a7a71b42e54.webp


64181e79ee3e5ab486ce3db929ecb4b2.webp


bfc2a059cf55811e784a0af0edd24463.webp


0b3ed0251deff15e7224ea554f6acc81.webp


1d4bbb9afe34708f1406c313f51a61ef.webp


c2edefa15c84424557a069c160d84814.webp


7296f1f851f9d978f66a7c0faa6a2f4a.webp


6f8a91983810b4620315396792378bf5.webp


ca24c30422cad5bf60c1035742db5f69.webp


7ab8c94bc76d93571ea0850903e90355.webp


4f450eab45030eaca498f87dd9b73e89.webp


329d6b411be982d14b1f319000aaad8b.webp


f505ab7d6918e0d89d2e64379ea4d580.webp


09ad47c55c2218c911bd0f5c269bf763.webp


267821cb10951b72e50215eaffc4d30e.webp


1efb2ef3d5a289036d1b6efdfa65ef6b.webp


62e703b055bba35c552ef21add937ca9.webp


bdca429ac17c69337ff434dba8cb73f0.webp



Open-air cures: State of the world got you down? Spend whatever you’ve got left on one of these convertibles.

With all the doom and gloom out there—evaporating 401k plans, exploding mortgages, pay cuts, Paula Abdul—this might seem like a bad time to buy a roadster. Two seats, flashy looks, extrovert performance, and a voracious fuel appetite are bound to anger your foreclosed neighbors faster than the Senate Finance Committee can bully you into returning your annual bonus. But if you haven’t already spent your ill-advised home-equity loan, now is the time to reward yourself with an automotive indulgence. If you are someone who still has a positive net worth, you can jump-start this knocked-down economy just by spending. And we’re here to help you make the best choice.

The idea was to round up a group of 50-something-thousand-dollar roadsters, but like the TARP plan, we blew through that ceiling almost immediately. The most egregious example is the Boxster S, which Porsche sent loaded with almost $20,000 worth of options—including the automaker’s new $3420 PDK dual-clutch transmission—for an overindulged as-tested price of $76,625. For 2009, the Boxster S comes with a revised 3.4-liter flat-six engine and freshened front and rear styling. It’s mostly direct injection that boosts the output 15 horsepower, for a total of 310.

Our second-most-pricey car is the new BMW Z4. The 300-hp sDrive35i starts at a not unreasonable $52,475, but a Sport package (which includes an adjustable suspension), a premium stereo, and a navigation system catapulted the sticker price to $65,345.

To paraphrase sputtering congressman Barney Frank, there are people who, for economic circumstances, must accept the inevitability of not being able to own. In that case, you can do what we did when Chevy couldn’t find a Corvette for our test—rent one for a few days. But we had to make do with a year-old 2008 model. If you ignore the 15,000 miles on its odometer, the rental is mechanically identical to an ’09, which would cost $62,720 new.

The only car that kept within our 50-something ballpark was the Audi TTS. It might even have arrived under that figure, but about seven grand worth of options put the as-tested price at $55,550, and that included $3000 for the Premium Plus package (the cheapest way to get a power softtop). The TTS comes with an upgraded 2.0-liter, turbocharged four-cylinder engine making 265 horsepower. In roadster form, the TTS folds its cloth roof into the rear seating area found in the coupe version.


* Fourth: 2009 Chevrolet Corvette
* Third: 2009 Audi TTS
* Second: 2009 BMW Z4 sDrive35i
* First: 2009 Porsche Boxster S




Full Story: Car and Driver - 09' Porsche Boxster S vs. BMW Z4 sDrive35i, Audi TTS, Chevy Corvette


M
 
Looks like the new Z4 is taking a back seat with driving dynamic.
It`s not as responsive as previously thought, so says the article. I still love the power-boat interior design!



BMW Z4
" Lows: Vague steering and odd suspension tuning are more suited to semi-relaxed driving."
 
Looks like the new Z4 is taking a back seat with driving dynamic.
It`s not as responsive as previously thought, so says the article. I still love the power-boat interior design!



BMW Z4
" Lows: Vague steering and odd suspension tuning are more suited to semi-relaxed driving."

I drove both the new Z4 and Audi TT Roadster the other day. Yes, its not as sporty as previous generation Z4 but its much more comfortable and luxurious. The new Z4 has become a more suitable for everyday use.
Regarding the steering, its superb, better than my babybimmer when you use sport mode.
The Roadster feel is still there and much more than the TT gives you.

Frankly, I dont understand the steering problem. Its fantastic in sportmode.
 
Honestly in the above collection I'd choose the Boxster S. I saw the Z4 IRL and I liked it but never drove it. But the Boxster is in different league, car feel expensive and that PDK is something to dream about. I like manuals but the PDK fast shifting is amazingly aggressive when you want it and silky smooth for daily driving.
 
^^ Me too; but in manual please.

On a side note, the Z4 is receiving amazingly bad reviews so far! Doesn't seem true to the spirit.
 
^^ Me too; but in manual please.

On a side note, the Z4 is receiving amazingly bad reviews so far! Doesn't seem true to the spirit.

I've driven the new Z4.

http://www.germancarforum.com/inter...-z4-sdrive-vs-audi-tt-roadster-testdrive.html

The new Z4 has become mature, thats for sure, previous Z4 was more of a sportsscar than the new Z4 but at the same time the suspension was stiffer.
In terms of Raodster feel, the car still stay true to the spirit. But now its more suitable for everyday use and here it doesnt stay true to the spirit.
Nonetheless, I had a blast with the new Z4 but I rather spend my money on Z4 3.0si Coupé, its still a cool car to drive and look at.


I have never driven a Boxster or a Cayman. I wish I had. Would be nice to see what people are talking about. Pekka, please come to Sweden :)
 
I drove both the new Z4 and Audi TT Roadster the other day. Yes, its not as sporty as previous generation Z4 but its much more comfortable and luxurious. The new Z4 has become a more suitable for everyday use.
Regarding the steering, its superb, better than my babybimmer when you use sport mode.
The Roadster feel is still there and much more than the TT gives you.

Frankly, I dont understand the steering problem. Its fantastic in sportmode.




BMW is leaning towards more luxury-oriented driver experiences. We might see this in the next 5er to.



Sayyaaf :Honestly in the above collection I'd choose the Boxster S. I saw the Z4 IRL and I liked it but never drove it. But the Boxster is in different league, car feel expensive and that PDK is something to dream about. I like manuals but the PDK fast shifting is amazingly aggressive when you want it and silky smooth for daily driving.


The Boxter is hands down the best car here, better performance, better reliability exc.. what more could you ask for. The only thing it lack a little is the sex-appeal factor.
 
Whaaat ? A porsche with little sex appeal ? come on man, I know I love the corvette and it could be sexy "especially in the states - its emotional :D" BUT a porsche is a porsche and chicks know it :D
 
I feel sorry for the Corvette. Back in 2006 it was the very car the Nissan GT-R is today - a supposed Porsche 911 killer fueled by Nurburgring times and praise from enthusiasts struggling to their themselves behind a steering wheel with a Stuttgart crest. Fast forward 3 years and the Z06 no longer get any mention in the price while the facelifted 997 is bright star in the sky.

As much as I'm a Porsche fan I'm very proud of both Audi and BMW. All three of the German cars in this article as amazing in their own way and there isn't anyone that I could rightfully turn down or claim isn't a desirable car. These are the reasons why I would chose to acquire either;

Z4: Best all-rounder and long term car.
Boxster S: The "true" sports car in the bunch with exhilarating driving dynamics.
TT-S: Visually highly distracting and is one hell of ahead turner and is the best choice for glitz.
 
Don't feel sorry for the Corvette, the ZR-1 will humiliate the GT-R and just about anything else on the road. The Corvette franchise is alive and well and its one of the rare cars that actually makes a profit for GM.

M
 
The numbers are dissappointing even with the M sport package. 0.83 g on the skidpad and over 3500 lbs as measured by C&D.

And people complain about the 135i........ which achieved 0.91 g on the same 200ft skidpad and about 200lbs lighter too. :confused:

I was expecting the new Z4 sDrive35i to be the newest and most sporty BMW product (outside of the pricy M cars). But it now seems that title is taken by 135i......which is fine by me..:D (I absolutely love my 135i as a part time track car)
 
Don't feel sorry for the Corvette, the ZR-1 will humiliate the GT-R and just about anything else on the road. The Corvette franchise is alive and well and its one of the rare cars that actually makes a profit for GM.

M

Exactly, no need to worry. If the ZR-1 is ever overtaken (lets face it, it could be that this is the end) there will be another one with even more power...
 
77k for a measly underpowered Boxster....a poor man's 911?

No thanks, I'd rather have a ZO6! :usa7uh:

Hell I'd rather have the Datsun also! :D

 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Poor old Boxster - the 911's wannabe alternative. Supposedly.

Actually, for many in the know, the Boxster S is one of the pinnacle open top drives available for any amount of money. Fortunately, I've been lucky enough to drive both the Boxster S and the E85 Z4 in a short timeframe apart. The Boxster was ever slightly the sportier of the two despite being more supply. The BMW was the more fun to drive and had the more charismatic engine. This says a lot for the old E85. This new car, clearly has been designed to grow up with its customers. I have no doubt though that, despite the negative reviews, as a consumer product the new Z4 will have much more mainstream appeal and will be as sporty as the vast majority of clients (including fussy people like me and Just_me) will be able to handle.

Having said that, I'd still opt for the new 987 Boxster S with new DI engine and manual box.
 

Thread statistics

Created
Merc1,
Last reply from
///K,
Replies
16
Views
7,337

Trending content


Back
Top