Cadillac XLR-V or Jaguar XKR Convertible?

[Andaluz]

Errr...I know this a forum dedicated to German cars.

But...

...These two particular brands, became the butt of the jokes on the luxury marques scenario.

Jaguar is in the middle of a deep financial crisis (and it shows). Cadillac is just plain stupid.

Be HONEST when voting!

Cadillac XLR-V

OR...

Jaguar XKR (2007 New Model)






?????????????????????????????????????????????????

 

[Mr. Chigga_Chan]

I'd probably take the Jag....

There is an "Other Car Brand" section of the forums btw.

 

[YoungWarrior]

xlr is the uglier of the two so it would be the Jag.

 

[Mr. M]

Jag for me too.

 

[kovachian]

They're both garbage so I'm casting my vote for NEITHER.

 

[zetableh]

First off, I appreciate your blatent insult of one of my favorite American brands. Remember, some of us actually like the cars produced by our country.

Secondly, I'll take the XLR-V, no question. Either in that red, or a dark blue, tan interior. There's no comparison between the brazen and bold lines of the Caddy and the soft curves of the Jag, at least for me.

 

[Geschwindigkeit]

I would have to say the jag also, i think the xlr-v has a nice interior, but it looks too much like a square!

 

[audi_rudy]

xlr-v any day over that ford/aston wannabe . I loved the xlr when it first came out in non v form and loving this even more. I would never consider it instead of a german convertable though

 

[Osnabrueck]

You know, I'd say XLR-V but...

the XLR is such a flimsy pile, I have to go with the Jag. If nothing the Jag has a passable interior that more or less gives off a luxury feeling, and a certain manner about it that's out of the ordinary.

The XLR-V seems so el cheapo when you step inside you'll do a double take. You feel for all the world like you're sitting in an Impala or something equally as daft.

 

[MikeJ]

XKR without a moment's hesitation. It's better-looking and for what I've heard, pretty good to drive as well.

 

[Giannis]

Jaguar all the way.. It looks so classy. No american car can beat it...