Vs Audi A5/S5 vs BMW 3-series E92 Coupé - the looks

[Tumbo]

Re: Ausi A5/S5 vs BMW 3-series E92 Coupé - the looks

I don't understand what we are comparing, Looks only or all the rest aswell ?

It's very clearly stated in the first post...LOOKS

 

[Zafiro]

Re: Ausi A5/S5 vs BMW 3-series E92 Coupé - the looks

Another example. Is the S5 that much better looking than the A5?

yes it is. Im not judging by photos. In real life S5 looks better to me. More presence in my book. I cant judg on base design only, its the total package for me.

 

[Deleted member 25]

Re: Ausi A5/S5 vs BMW 3-series E92 Coupé - the looks

Then what's the point of talking about prices and how good are the lower engines ?

 

[Tumbo]

Re: Ausi A5/S5 vs BMW 3-series E92 Coupé - the looks

Then what's the point of talking about prices and how good are the lower engines ?

Cause it's a forum... Does a thread always stay on topic? Of course no. But the thread title says clearly...the looks.

 

[GTA45E]

The Audi A5/S5, without question.. it`s more beautiful in every way.
BMW simply doesn`t make a beautiful car. Handsome maby but not beautiful.

 

[Zafiro]

The Audi A5/S5, without question.. it`s more beautiful in every way.
BMW simply doesn`t make a beautiful car. Handsome maby but not beautiful.

but still you think CLK is better looking than A5?

 

[DeDe]

A5/S5 for me. 3er Coupe looks old and boring comparing to them.

 

[Bruce]

I'm torn. Having seen both in the flesh, my intial reaction was that the Audi has the better rear-end, whilst the the 3er has the more appealing front end. Wasn't fond of the grill detailing on the S5 to be down right honest. Although, I would agree with those who have said the S5 looks heaps better than the A5.

Overall? Can't decide at the moment.

 

[GTA45E]

but still you think CLK is better looking than A5?

lOl Just_me, you crack me up sometimes!

You know I`m an MB fan so the CLK has to come in the picture.

(The CLK isn`t being discussed here..)

Ok, let me answer your question.. The CLK has a sort of sex appeal with the sport-package. There are quit a few CLK running around in my area. The design is a little too cute though ( as Klier pointed out on the previous SL, I happen to agree) both has almost the same face.. but I think its better looking than the A5/S5? no.. I think the A5 has more beautiful lines as a total package. The CLK is quit feminine looking which is why I think its more sexy.

 

[PanterroR]

Diesel or petrol, S line vs. M Package, the A5 comes NOWHERE CLOSE to E92, period! Oh and the fact that Audi needs a V8 with 4.2L to compete with TT I6 is also a good fact to mention. Interior? That's a different story and there Audi wins; but i'm not buying my car because of it's interior.

You disagree? Tell me something i didn't know.

E92 over A5/S5 any day!

 

[siko]

Hard to anaswer the poll:

• A5 over non-335i
• 335 over A5
• S5 over 335
• M3 over S5

.... i'm not comparing this by using engines, 335 has a dual symetrical exaust, other E92s dont!

... S5/M3 have different body kits.

 

[Merc1]

Hard to anaswer the poll:

• A5 over non-335i
• 335 over A5
• S5 over 335
• M3 over S5

.... i'm not comparing this by using engines, 335 has a dual symetrical exaust, other E92s dont!

... S5/M3 have different body kits.

And there you have it, summed up perfectly me for me.

M

 

[Mr Robert]

1. M3
2. S5
3. M-sport E92
4. S-line A5
5. E92
6. A5

 

[Tumbo]

Hard to anaswer the poll:

• A5 over non-335i
• 335 over A5
• S5 over 335
• M3 over S5

And in one year:

• RS5 over M3

 

[Tumbo]

You guys don't seem to get my point here.
Screw the bumpers, the engines, the wheels, the grilles.... I want to hear about the DESIGN of the car itself. That's what's important here, and that where I see the E92 being no competition for the absolutely amazing A5/S5 and I now understand why Wlater Da Silva said it's the most beautiful car he has ever designed.

 

[Deleted member 25]

E92 all the way.

 

[dOmInIX]

There is a 3.0 TDI A5 here in my town and it is absolutely amazing car. I love how it is designed, it has that provocative, modern and very attractive design. Every time this car passes by me I want the guy to stop so I can admire the car. It's true, LEDs look amazing also! Not to start about perfect interior..

On the other side, I see E92 Coupe more subtle designed, not so much attractive though it has that something that also makes it cool..

So, regarding the design I would take A5 over 3er Coupe, that for sure...But the 335s' twin turbo over the A5s' 3.O that also for sure.

It would take me some time to decide if I had to choose which one to buy..

 

[hussein]

aunistly i would choose the s5 all the way because i never liked the 3 series and i do not know why i just hate it the audi is like one of only one of the best coupes ive ever seen and im just talking streetwise not all types of sports cars

 

[MoSs]

the e92 is a beautifull car but it has no chance next to the beauty of the S5

 

[Mr Robert]

And in one year:

• RS5 over M3

And then:

• M3 CSL over RS5