• As a reminder, this section is for civil discussions only. In general, be courteous to others. Debate/discuss/argue the merits of ideas, don't attack people. Personal insults, shill or troll accusations, hate speech, any advocating or wishing death/physical harm, and other rule violations can result in a permanent ban. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them.

The real reason why Iran is a huge threat to USA?


EnI

Piston Pioneer
WOULD IRAN'S OIL PLAN TO KILL THE U.S. DOLLAR START ANOTHER WAR IN THE REGION?

On the 20th of this month, Iran will commit a far greater "offense" than what the toppled Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein did in the fall of 2002 when he announced shifting Iraq’s oil exports to the euro.

Numerous analyst and U.S. officials have repeatedly stated that the Pentagon has prepared plans for a military strike against Iran, partially to force Iran scrap its nuclear activities and partially due to Iran’s decision to shift to the Euro which will have a devastating impact on the U.S. currency’s hegemony and the once strong economy.

Iran’s plan is to begin competing with New York's NYMEX and London's IPE with respect to international oil trades - using a euro-denominated international oil-trading mechanism. Which will, if the U.S. failed to scruple this plan, allow the euro establish a firm foothold in the international oil trade. And bearing in minds the U.S. debt levels, Iran's upcoming euro-based oil Bourse will be an obvious encroachment on U.S. dollar supremacy in global oil market

So in less than three weeks, we’ll see many countries buying and selling oil and gas not only for dollars but also for euros.

The new oil bourse, which will establish a new oil “marker” (oil pricing standard) based on Iranian crude, in open rivalry to the existing West Texas Intermediate, Norway Brent and UAE Dubai markers, all calculated in U.S. dollars, will provide a golden opportunity to countries and companies concerned about having to hold huge amounts of U.S. dollars to finance their oil transactions, stated an editorial on Arab News.

Worried about the huge deficits its economy already suffers, the U.S. knows, and is deeply alarmed by the danger Iran’s new oil bourse means, as it might result in the dollar losing its status as the world’s only reserve currency.

So to prevent the Euro from emerging as an alternative reserve currency, the U.S. government is determined to stop the Iranian experiment.

But some of the U.S. scenario-mongers would resort to a preemptive strike against Iran before it even opens the bourse, the Arab News editorial further states, adding that an alternative scenario could be pushing Israel do the dirty work of for Washington, launching a devastating air strike targeting the Islamic republic’s nuclear sites, recalling what happened with the former Iraqi leader.

A similar initiative taken by Saddam Hussein in 2002 resulted in the quagmire still going in Iraq up till this day, the March 2003 war, although, as analysts stated, no solid evidence had ever linked Hussein’s demand to be paid in euros for Iraq’s oil with the U.S. invasion of Iraq.

However, some analysts suggest that the Bush administration might not be planning to attack Iran to stop it from establishing its euro-based oil bourse which stands as a real challenge to the dollar, arguing that the current U.S. government doesn’t worry much about such things.

But in case Washington attacks Iran, whether directly or by having Israel doing it, Iran is definitely ready for a heavy retaliation.

Iran has promised a “crushing response” to any U.S. or Israeli attack. Ironically, Iran doesn’t have the nuclear weapons to scare off attackers, but it does have other options, with ground forces estimated at 800,000 personnel, as well as long-range missiles capable of hitting Israel and Europe.

Also much of the world’s oil supply is transported through the Strait of Hormuz, a narrow stretch of ocean which Iran borders to the north.

Moreover, attacking Iran will plant the seeds of tension in the already troubled Middle East nation, especially provoking the Shia Community in Iraq.


Source AlJazeera

************

In simple words:

The reason the U.S. dollar is threatened is because high demand for the U.S. dollar and Treasury Bills exist because foreigners need dollars to purchase resources in the primary markets for commodities, specifically oil. Because the U.S. and England, its subsidiary/sponsor, have controlled the major markets and denominated them in dollars, large numbers of dollars have been required to purchase oil and other commodities.

If Iran establishes a successful foreign exchange system in euros, dollars will no longer be needed for international oil and presumably later commodities purchases, because these purchases could now be made in euros. These dollars would be repatriated into the U.S. economy causing massive inflation.

The Chinese and Japanese who have kept high dollar reserves and intervened in the free market for their own currencies in order to support the dollar system would likely watch their exports market dry up or face unimaginable levels of currency intervention to save the trade system they have erected. In any case, they would be unable to create enough yuan and yen to do so without going bankrupt themselves. At some point they will have to give up their heroic efforts to save their American trade empire. World could be facing a disastrous total global economic failure.

Americans will face massive hyperinflation, total economic collapse lead by housing and the stock market, which have been largely supported by inflows of these foreign dollars back into our banking system, allowing for the creation of the massive number of loans because of increased dollar reserves. Unemployment will skyrocket, and poverty will become endemic within a few years of the collapse due to foreclosures and layoffs.

To save their political futures, the Republican leadership and Neocons will possibly try to start a war with Iran if they can and seize their oil assets and destroy the idea of this market. If they don't, their political futures are nill. If they do, their political future is very likely also nil. In any case, the oil wars are about to begin in earnest it seems or perhaps some last minute negotiations can stave off disaster.

It is clear that we are in a very precarious situation at best, and the best diplomacy would be to negotiate with Iran, though they appear to be non negotiable about WMD or oil bourses. If no negotiations can succeed, it would appear that the given the current administration and the current political situation in Washington, combined with Wall Street and the vast oil industrial government machine complex, that war is unavoidable unless the people decide to change their way of life.

Source: Blogcritics


PS:
Venezuela is supporting Iran's plans
Now Iran and Venezuela have joined together to gain independence from the U.S. Dollar. Venezuela's president Chavez supports the opening of the Iran Oil Bourse on March 20, 2006. The Iran Oil Bourse will challenge U.S. dollar supremacy in global oil market transactions executed on the New York Mercantile Exchange and London's International Petroleum Exchange by creating the opportunity for countries to shift foreign-exchange holdings out of dollars and into euros or other currencies.
Iran And Venezuela are world's 4th and 5th biggest net oil exporting countries.


Your comments, guys?
 
interesting... but maybe somewhat overstated. The article seems to give the impression that if Iran does go with the Euro, then in two months time the American economy collapses... not very likely. But all in all, the US Dollar has been heading this way for a while now, and it can't/won't be able to maintain its monopoly position in the global trade markets. The euro is simply getting too strong and too important, whether Europe likes it or not (hell, prices have sky rocketed for years now).

I personally think its a good thing. Long term wise, this is the only way to go since no market can be sustained if there is only one player in it. America supports (invented almost) the market economy and now they'll have to play by their own rules... sorry to say, but america is heading for a rough period and W. really has only dug the hole deeper.
 
Roberto said:
Good post EniLab - but it is quite typical AlJazeera propaganda.

He he, no different from the propoganda drummed into the masses by the western media.

Maybe counter propoganda will result in some sort of balance, lol. :D
 
Folks, is there really a need to discuss about those things here...? C'mon, few conversations about this were already ended/locked by admins because it always ends up in a worst way... This is my opinion only, no offence, but i don't think that subject should be discussed at GermanCarForum web site.

:t-cheers:
 
I for one enjoy these off-topic discussions greatly.
This site is made up of (mostly) intelligent and knowledgeable people but with very different backgrounds. You always get all sorts of different views. Granted, many of these threads do turn ugly but I don't think it's a reason not to have them in the first place.
 
man US should stay out of iran.. they are allready in above their heads..
it could turn out to be very very nasty..
 
MikeJ said:
I for one enjoy these off-topic discussions greatly.
This site is made up of (mostly) intelligent and knowledgeable people but with very different backgrounds. You always get all sorts of different views. Granted, many of these threads do turn ugly but I don't think it's a reason not to have them in the first place.

Mike, there's nothing wrong with what you've just said, but still these are the car forums. Off-topic section is for all other stuff, even for these kind of conversations, but none of has have good expirience with those discussions so far and that's why i think that it should not be discussed at all, even if some enjoy it.

My two cents, peace, i'm out...

:t-cheers:
 
Hmmm...this seems like crap.
The strenght of the dollar is one of the reasons of America's trade and budget deficit.
Countries such as Japan, S. Koreea and China are manipulating their curencies to give their exports an unfair advantage and in doing so their are causing america's manufacturing sector decline.
Germany, Europe's no.1 economy is living thru exports. It is the no.1 exporter in the world, ahead of Japan, China or the USA, and quite frankly the strong euro
is bad for it.
Now if I was an US president I would put some import taxes on the countries that play unfair trade and use that money to perhaps, invade Venezuela. I mean get rid of some semi oficial south american dictator, thus make ing the world a better place and protecting America's interests.
 
Sorry that is one of those legends which are announced by the 'fans of conspiracy' :eusa_doh:

1st thesis:
Trading with EUR wil weakening the Dollar and the US:

The amount of iran oil which ist traded worldwide is very low.
iran traded 55 billion dollar in 2005. Exxon Mobile has a trading volume
of 360 billion dollar alone! a war would instead weaken more the dollar because of the high deficite now.

2. thesis: Iran wants to establish his own trade bourse
Not very possible that will be a thread. If its happening: Who will trade there his oil? Russia? Not very possible. Saudi Arabia isnt trading its oil. Others like
Asserbaidschan are economicaly to much bounded to the US.
Also Iran has no financial instruments and the knowledge/people/it-infrastructure for things like Swaps and Forward Sales.
Even Singapour hasnt managed it to build up a trade bourse....

and so on....
 
gustavo said:
Sorry that is one of those legends which are announced by the 'fans of conspiracy' :eusa_doh:

It's fun to read. :D

But: where is smoke, there is also a fire. ;)

The amount of iran oil which ist traded worldwide is very low.
iran traded 55 billion dollar in 2005. Exxon Mobile has a trading volume
of 360 billion dollar alone!

Venezuela supports Irans plans. Iran and Venezuela are world's 4th and 5th biggest oil exporters (after KSA, Russia & Norway).

Iran wants to establish his own trade bourse
Not very possible that will be a thread. If its happening: Who will trade there his oil? Russia? Not very possible.

China & Japan perhaps? They are already biggest oil importers from Iran.
But the Venezuela role is even more important - if they start to trade in euros, that will hurt US more - since Venezuala is 4th biggest US oil supplier.
 
EniLab said:
It's fun to read. :D

But: where is smoke, there is also a fire. ;)

I think it's BS :D

EniLab said:
Venezuela supports Irans plans. Iran and Venezuela are world's 4th and 5th biggest oil exporters (after KSA, Russia & Norway).

China & Japan perhaps? They are already biggest oil importers from Iran.
But the Venezuela role is even more important - if they start to trade in euros, that will hurt US more - since Venezuala is 4th biggest US oil supplier.

The amount of Iran and Venezuelas oil trading is realy small, compared to the others( wordwide share: Venzuela ~ 3% and Iran ~ 7% ). I wont affect the US in a noteworthy manner if they bill in euros. And there is no statement from irna or any other iran newspaper that they will do that. And do you think that Kish (20.000 inhabitants) will be a competitor to NY or London? :D

It will be more interesting to see, what China will do with it's huge cash reserves. THAT will have an influence on the Greenback
 

Trending content


Back
Top