The hottest Audi right now - S5 or R8?

[SDNR]

I am totally crazy about the R8 right now.

 

[NarutoRamen]

Honestly, this was not the right poll. The S5 is good looking car but it pales in comparison to the R8.

 

[Choleric]

S5:

I could live in there.

 

[Matt]

how abut the rs4?

 

[Deleted member 182]

I am totally crazy about the R8 right now.

Me too.

 

[HighestOfHigh]

I prefer the S5. The R8 is a excellent attempt by Audi, but not favorite. The s5 actually looks like something I wouldn't mind driving on a daily basis. It has very smooth likes and the interior is very clean cut.

Does anyone know if it will be getting a big brother? (S7 - A6 coupe or something)

 

[klier]

You expected it to? It wasn't created to topple those cars! It's purpose is to be a luxury coupe with a hint of high performance capabilities if my understanding is correct. But you can be sure that the RS5 will fill all the gaps left by the S5!

P.S
335i vs. S5
M3 vs. RS5
M3 sedan vs. RS4

Why don't you see that the 335i is a regular BMW, while the S5 and M3 ARE NOT regular models. Your logic is completely flawed.

You shouldn't start comparing regular models with S/RS/M/M CSL models. Just because the new M3 is already in the league of the Audi RS model doesn't mean the M3 CSL is suddenly out of the picture. The RS line is Audi's most extreme model, the CSL line is BMW's. Live with it please. An S5 is way more expensive than a 335i too.

 

[ateekt]

Pasta or Sushi, I'll take anything but spicy & here I'll go for "R8" ...!

 

[RICHBOY]

Why don't you see that the 335i is a regular BMW, while the S5 and M3 ARE NOT regular models. Your logic is completely flawed.

You shouldn't start comparing regular models with S/RS/M/M CSL models. Just because the new M3 is already in the league of the Audi RS model doesn't mean the M3 CSL is suddenly out of the picture. The RS line is Audi's most extreme model, the CSL line is BMW's. Live with it please. An S5 is way more expensive than a 335i too.

O Klier, why is it you continue to address me? It usually leads to one of your BMW moderator friends warning me! So if it's your intent to bate me into some BS then just move on, You know I don't back down! You said "The RS line is Audi's most extreme model, the CSL line is BMW's. Live with it please." I was unaware they shared the same goal. Audi's RS line doesn't sacrifice it's plush interior to boost performance, unlike BMW's CSL removing seats, dramatically reducing the weight in every way possible. I was wondering Klier, when did Audi go to such measures for maximize performance? Becuase if they didn't what was the point you were trying to make? I know you'd like to think BMW's CSL is a plush cruising machine that you'd love to take the family cross country in, but it's not! Audi's S5 and BMW's 335i aren't that far apart price wise IMO. I don't expect you to agree with me, but that's your opinion. I know it bothers you hearing how the soon to be replaced RS4 still takes the crown from the M3, but hey, get over it! I know I don't care, unless there comparing the RS4 and the M3 sedan what's the point? As I said before....

RS4 vs. M3 Sedan
RS5 vs. M3 Coupe
??? vs. M3 CSL

I'm pretty sure most the members here would agree!

 

[LaArtist]

??? vs. M3 CSL

RS5+ maybe

 

[RICHBOY]

??? vs. M3 CSL

RS5+ maybe

I highly doubt Audi's gonna pull the back seats as well as other weight reducing modifications to challenge BMW's M3 CSL! I don't think it makes good financial sense regardless of the outcome.

 

[Tumbo]

RS4 vs. M3 Sedan
RS5 vs. M3 Coupe

I'm pretty sure most the members here would agree!

Yupp. It's just the way it is. If anybody thinks different, it's just weird in my opinion.

 

[VroomVroom]

ooooooooooooooooh this is hard......they both beautiful car....the r8 is fast but not really practical and the s5 is quite fast and "sort ov" practical , but my vote had to go on the s5 but if the rs5 comes out make a new poll.....r8 or the rs5

 

[RICHBOY]

ooooooooooooooooh this is hard......they both beautiful car....the r8 is fast but not really practical and the s5 is quite fast and "sort ov" practical , but my vote had to go on the s5 but if the rs5 comes out make a new poll.....r8 or the rs5

I prefer polling the RS5 vs. M3 coupe vs. CLK63

RS5

 

[Deutsch]

This is a real question? Hilarious.