- Messages
- 8,624
This is a fun comparison. Although I am not surprised that they dissed the 996, the 996 is starting to catch people’s eye. Although it lacks the round headlights, the 996C4S is gorgeous in blue with turbine alloys. Most crucially the 996 drives as well as the 997 but for considerably less money.
![]()
![]()
![]()
I agree that the base 996 variant aren't the crown jewels of the 911. However the 996 C4S is coming around and is getting more coverage on YouTube. IMO it's a distinctive looking 911 and is less soft/skinny at the rear compared with a 997CS or C4S. Although the 996TT is attractive I do like the "touring" look of the C4S.My least favorite 911 series. But man...this particular example looks pretty damn smart. 996 Carrera 4s coupe with the Turbo Rotor 5 spokes in satin silver...Yep-that's quite a number.
The IMS failure is lower than the Internet can make people believe. If catastrophic engine failure is a worry than the IMS and clutch can be upgraded for £2,000/$2,400/€2,400 for peace of mind. This is not crazy money compared consider the age of a 996 or 997.^996's flaws were more than skin deep. Everything was cheap about it - the interior bits, the tactile stuff, the way the doors closed and of course the worst - the IMS bearing issues with the M96 engine. Only the Mezger powered variants - Turbo, GT3, GT2 were spared from it. And yes, the IMS issues lingered on to the early 997s to, so I would stay away from them too.
Of course, all the cheap stuff helped Porsche survive a lean patch, so credit where it is due. But I wouldn't go buy a non-GT 996.
The dream is a GT3 but financially I am there yet. Used 997GTS are priced like gold dust, thankfully the 6 cylinder 718 GTS has come to the rescue. My priority is driving enjoyment and I don’t mind whether the car is 1 or 10 years old. Newer cars are brilliant for many reasons but some leave me a bit numb unless driven at the limit.^Sure. But why? Unless you are fixated on owning a 911 for the sake of it and is too broke for another. There are far better cars to be had for the same coin.
The dream is a GT3 but financially I am there yet. Used 997GTS are priced like gold dust, thankfully the 6 cylinder 718 GTS has come to the rescue. My priority is driving enjoyment and I don’t mind whether the car is 1 or 10 years old. Newer cars are brilliant for many reasons but some leave me a bit numb unless driven at the limit.
My priority is driving enjoyment
Ha! Honda S2000. Good call. Maybe it's because I am approaching my mid 30s but the desire for a convertible is strong. I have driven a 981 Cayman and Cayman S.Few thoughts -
Be a little wary of the GT3 dream. Before the 991, they are very raw and not a car best used daily. Awesome, weekend/track cars.
Agree with you so much on the older cars being more fun...but I would consider many other cars from that era before a 996 - E36/46 M3, M coupe, S2000 all come to top of my head. If Porsche, 987 (especially .2) and 981 anyday over a 996.
Unless you are fixated on owning a 911 for the sake of it and is too broke for another.
Isn't this a legitimate petrolhead dream, though? Everything you mentioned (i.e. M3, S2000, etc) follows the typical front engine RWD layout. The 911 anatomy is something completely different and I think something work trying. The 996 is the easiest way in.
I've been looking through the 996 offerings in Greece for a while now, for exactly the reason you wrote. I'm too broke for another. A nice 996 Carrera S for 20 to 25k though, is not that bad of a deal in a market where an entry level 997 with less than 200.000 km will got for around 40k euros. Not that I intend to buy one in the near future, but as a thought exercise.
Sure, there are better, far better cars to have. I'd be a fool not to know that, especially after 15 years of being a member hereBut if you just want a great driving experience, and agnostic of the engine layout/weight bias...
If the rear engine dynamics is the exprecince you are explicitly seeking, then, definitely, 996 is a great entry point. But if you just want a great driving experience, and agnostic of the engine layout/weight bias...
You know the real reason why they don't do a Turbo S in Targa format (whereas they do in Cabrio)?Screw laptimes. Just cruise in this car and let the worms around you rush.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.