Bridster
Oversteer Expert
- Messages
- 1,316
There is a big difference between Newey and Murray, though.you can have said the same about Murray when he designed the F1, look how awesome that turned out.
Newey has literally done nothing but designing single seater racers ever since he enrolled to college. His first job was in F1, then he did CART briefly, and then he got back in F1 where he's been ever since for the last 34 years. As far as I know he never designed anything else.
Murray, on the other hand, started by building his own race car (which was basically a Lotus 7 replica) at 20, built himself a road legal car (the Minbug) once he emigrated to the UK, built a couple of one-off road cars and finally created the LCC Rocket. So before he ever got to doing the F1 he had acquired a lot of experience.
Either way, that's probably not even the biggest problem. After all, just because Newey and Murray were the chief designers doesn't mean they designed the whole car themselves. They would serve mostly as directors, communicating their vision to the engineering teams which would actually be doing the job. Of course, with more experience your vision should be the better developed and more successful one, but without skilled colleagues it's not gonna work out that great. The problem for Newey was that he was surrounded on one side by his Red Bull guys who probably wouldn't have much experience with designing road cars either, and on the other side by AM guys who never designed anything with performance in their lives.