Need some purchase advice..


MichaelAMG

Autobahn Newbie
Hey everyone, firstly I'd like to introduce myself as I'm new to the forum, so hello to everyone. I've joined because I've been a silent reader of this forum from time to time, just because I get some really good insight from reading some posts. However, today I'm in need of some advice.. I've been an AMG guy my entire life, and I've tried a couple of BMWs out in my lifetime (2007 335i cabrio & a 550i). However, when I sold my last AMG in 2011 (CLS), I decided I wanted a change for a year or two, so I purchased an Audi s4 and remained very disappointed, not because it's not a good car, but because naturally it is in a much lower class than a CLS amg, so I was underwhelmed generally - but great car otherwise.

Now it's time for a new car.. I'm not sure if I'll go for a 2012 C63 AMG coupe with the development package & fully loaded or a 507 edition, or if I'll go for a 2012/2013 BMW M5. So, I'm here for some advice.. I know the AMG hits 0-60 almost a full second quicker from my research (C63 is around 3.6s, M5 is around 4.4s), the AMG's interior is much nicer(red and black two tone) as I think the M5's interior is a bit dull, but it does look very luxury and spacey. The exhaust sound from the AMG is incredible, but the M5 isn't too bad either.

Now I'm just tied up as to which one looks better from the outside, I can't decide and this is ultimately the most important factor in deciding for me so I want some opinions. I also want to know which car would be more reliable if anyone knows, and finally what the depreciation is like on either car, I know AMG's depreciate quite badly because I've lost money on the few I've owned, but then again you have 335's now that you can purchase for under $20,000 before tax that were $75,000 or w.e brand new so.. Any advice helps, thanks a lot guys.
 
If I understand correctly you are choosing between a C63 507 edition or a '13 M5. Between those two I'd pick the M5 hands down.
 
Looks wise, the M5 is king.
Exhaust nose, AMG of course. Especially a 6.3.

If you're worried about depreciation, no AMG or M car will save you. Actually, no German car will :D.
 
If I understand correctly you are choosing between a C63 507 edition or a '13 M5. Between those two I'd pick the M5 hands down.

Sorry, I just realized my post was quite confusing to read :D. What I meant was, I'm looking at two different C63 AMG's and an M5. One is a 2012 C63 AMG coupe with the development package + fully loaded, and the other one is the 507 edition. So it's either one of those two OR the M5. I'm beginning to lean towards to M5, not only because it's better looking, but because I've never really owned a top end performance car from BMW, it wil be a new experience.

Thanks for all the advice guys, and thanks for the welcome W201.

@Yaz, lol! I wish I could get my hands on a black series.. They shouldn't depreciate as badly, but I'm finding it almost impossible to find one at the moment.
 
Sorry, I just realized my post was quite confusing to read :D. What I meant was, I'm looking at two different C63 AMG's and an M5. One is a 2012 C63 AMG coupe with the development package + fully loaded, and the other one is the 507 edition. So it's either one of those two OR the M5. I'm beginning to lean towards to M5, not only because it's better looking, but because I've never really owned a top end performance car from BMW, it wil be a new experience.

Thanks for all the advice guys, and thanks for the welcome W201.

@Yaz, lol! I wish I could get my hands on a black series.. They shouldn't depreciate as badly, but I'm finding it almost impossible to find one at the moment.
Ah ok got it! I have driven both (C 63 AMG Coupe and M6 GC) and the M6 GC was just on another level. Not taking anything away from the M156, but the 4.4L engine is just awesome.

 
Ah ok got it! I have driven both (C 63 AMG Coupe and M6 GC) and the M6 GC was just on another level. Not taking anything away from the M156, but the 4.4L engine is just awesome.

That u drivin?
And @MichaelAMG depends on what you want, really... The M5 is my favorite here! But in the end it comes down to preference! And i have to say... The M5 takes on the E63, so technicaly it beats the C content wise... I guess...
 
Thanks for the replies everyone. So it looks like everyone went for the M5... I just recently signed the papers for the C63 though :D I gave this dealership the biggest headaches because I went and test drove both cars twice each, and kept going in to look at them. That's just how I am when I pick a car though, I need to make sure I love it. At the end of the day, for some reason the C63 provided me more driving thrills. BTW, I didnt go for the 507, I went for the 2012 C63 Coupe with the development package+fully loaded. Only 24,000km which is nothing, the 507 was just as nice but had 38,000km and I didn't like the interior as much as the red one in the other c63.

At the end of the day, I couldn't get over the soulless interior of the M5, looking at it from outside I thought it was beautiful (and yes, probably nicer than the c63), but sitting inside of it I didn't feel like I was in a sports car, or even a high end car for that matter.
 

Thread statistics

Created
MichaelAMG,
Last reply from
MichaelAMG,
Replies
11
Views
572

Trending content


Back
Top