Being 4 seconds faster at Castle Combe than a race lap record (so not even a qualifying lap - which would be faster - from the F3 car) of a 240 hp Dallara F317 is a good feat, but not super impressive.
They said they were running at 80% power (so around 810 ps peak power), but - AFAIK - they did not mention this time the % of employed downforce from the active fan.
I hope they were not running with 100% fan downforce, otherwise this result would be disappointing.
But, given that 4 seconds margin on this circuit over a 58.5 s lap time from a F317 would roughly be equal to a 1'41-1'42 lap time at Silverstone - compared to the current lap record from a F317 which is 1'49.7 - there is a good chance that the Speirling Pure was running here as well with 80% downforce level.
In fact, with 80% power and 80% downforce settings the car clocked a high 1'40 lap time in Silverstone earlier this year.
Back to the Castle Combe lap time, I said not super impressive because a Dallara F317 is not even a current official FIA F3 car, but rather a Formula 3 one.
The FIA F3 race car is in fact the current Dallara F3 2019 (which will be soon replaced by the upcoming F3 2025), which packs 380 hp and is significantly faster than the F317.
In fact, at Silverstone, while the race lap record of the F317 is the previously mentioned 1'49.7 time, a Dallara F3 2019 clocked a significantly faster 1'45.7 lap time.
Now, we know that the Speirling Pure is even faster than that (clocked a high 1'40 lap time at Silverstone, as already mentioned), but I would have expected a bigger gap over a F317 at Castle Combe.
In any case, regarding the Speirling, the required jump to match serious F1 lap times is quite huge.
It is true that, thanks to its active fan, the Speirling has big downforce edge over everything else at low-to-medium speeds, however from a certain speed value onward the advantage of a F1 is going to be massive.
For example, the downforce-to-weight curve (as function of speed) of the Speirling Pure is basically a flat line from 0 km/h to its top speed. There is in fact a minimal dependency from the square value of velocity due to the rear wing (but we are talking about a very low amount of downforce of 250 kg at around 241 km/h), while everything else is provided by the active fan (so, at full beans, claimed 2000 kg from 0 km/h onwards).
This means that, compared for example to a 2021 low-mid end F1 car, the Speirling Pure has a significant downforce-to-weight advantage until around 160 km/h. Then, from 160 km/h to around 200 km/h this advantage is considerably reduced and at around 205-210 km/h there is the turning point in favour of the F1 car.
But the downforce-to-weight profile of the F1 car increases with the square of velocity while that of the Speirling stays basically flat, so for example at 260 km/h the Speirling still has a downforce-to-weight ratio of around 2 while the F1 car is already hitting and then quickly surpassing a value of 3.
So, in high-speed tracks such as Silverstone or Spa the Speirling is going to have a clear disadvantage in high speed corners compared to F1s and, to ultimately match their lap times, it has to totally compensate in low-speed turns thanks to its fan-driven downforce at the immediate power delivery of its electric powertrain.
This can theoretically be done but it's not an easy feat to accomplish in practice, also because the LMP2 tyres of the Pure are way narrower and with far less mechanical grip compared to soft or qualy slick tyres of post-2017 F1 cars.
Moreover, nobody basically mentioned this fact, but on McMurtry website they are claiming that the battery pack capacity of the Speirling Pure has been increased to 100 kWh.
This, however, led to a claimed weight increase of 200 kg, going from the original 1000 kg value to 1200 kg.
And a 200 kg negative delta in weight is a massive penalty when you are trying to get close to modern F1 lap times around a track.
Then, they theoretically could increase downforce to compensate, however a combination of 1200 kg weight (with no driver) + 2000+ kg of downforce is already exceeding the 3.2 tons mark, which is probably already not far away at all from the load limit of the fitted LMP2 tyres.
So yeah, overall the Speirling Pure is obviously a very, very fast track car but is has not an easy task to accomplish in its pursuing of modern F1 cars lap times.
I am interested in the upcoming developments and next steps from McMurtry to see how they are going to face this challenge.