Vs Autoexpress: New BMW 5-Series vs Jaguar XF

[Betty Swollocks]

No, it's based on putting the cars head to head for a couple of hours. 5er wins. With countless of hours behind the wheel of the 5er, the gap will only increase

And you've done that have you?

 

[HighestOfHigh]

Honestly the BMW should drive much better then the Jag. BMW has had time to improve everything plus it's a completely new model.

Although I like the new 5 series, the Jaguar would probably be my choice because it looks better (IMO).

 

[mentir]

I'm impressed with the sleekness of the F10's design. XF remains my top choice in this segment but the new 5er comes in a close second.

 

[Zafiro]

British carmagazine 'Whatcar' had a comparison between new E-class and Jaguar XF and they gave first place to the Jag.

 

[klier]

British carmagazine 'Whatcar' had a comparison between new E-class and Jaguar XF and they gave first place to the Jag.

British bias. That's impossible.

 

[Zafiro]

British bias. That's impossible.

They gave the new 5er a 5 star rating. Just wait until they try Jag vs new 5er, there will be a german winner

 

[Betty Swollocks]

British bias. That's impossible.

You really do yourself no favours Klier. Just accept somebody's decision gracefully.

 

[klier]

You really do yourself no favours Klier. Just accept somebody's decision gracefully.

LOL, stop being so serious all the time. I don't even mean it man. They can like the Citroen C6 more than the new 5er as far as I'm concerned. No biggie

 

[klier]

 

[DFresh23]

Traded in my e60 for an XF the weekend the f10 was revealed. It looked to conservative for me. Too much like an stretched out e90.

I hope BMW does not disappoint with the new 6.