Comparison tests 2015 Audi TT Roadster vs 2014 BMW Z4


Which would you choose?


  • Total voters
    26

ThroughandThrough

Kraftkurve King
2015 Audi TT Roadster vs 2014 BMW Z4: Roadster Comparison

722fa9967999aaad8ec9879e10e80ec3.webp


Now that Audi released their latest iteration of the TT Roadster, a comparison with BMW’s only model that fits the description was mandatory. We’re talking about the Z4 Roadster, of course, the only 2-seater the Munich-based company is making at the moment.

That’s a rather interesting fact, considering that BMW claims to be a sporty-oriented brand for spirited drivers. On the other hand, Mercedes-Benz, a company that is more comfort-oriented, has a lot more 2 seaters in its line-up. Just food for thought.

Getting back on point here, we should mention that the Z4 is a big longer compared to the TT, measuring 63 mm more at 4,239 mm (166.9 inches) but narrower with a width of 1,791 mm (70.5 inches) compared to Audi’s 1,831 mm (164.4 inches) and lower, sitting at 1,290 mm (50.8 inches), 64 mm closer to the ground. The wheelbase is nearly identical, with a slight, 7 mm advantage for the Audi TT that has 2,504 mm in between the wheels.

The exterior design

The BMW E89 Z4 is now in its final years of production. Last year, the model received what the company calls a Life Cycle Impulse or LCI for short. That’s just Bimmer-lingo for facelift but the changes aren’t easily noticeable.

That means, in this battle, BMW goes in wearing a design that’s 5 years old. Even so, from the outside it looks just as on par with the trends as on the day it was released. The short overhangs offer it a sporty allure while the creases in the body make it seem aggressive without trying too hard.

On the other hand, the Audi is a good-looker. It’s very well hooked in the 21st century and it’s showing a fresh face compared to all the other models in the line-up that basically look the same. The front fascia is where the magic happens while the back looks more like an evolution.

What about inside?

Inside the win goes to the Audi, hands-down. Everything is brand new, from the air vents and digital instrument cluster to the brilliant seats inside the TTS version. Everything looks magnificent and worthy of a car that folds its roof to reveal its insides.

On the other hand, the Z4 is not bad at all. Out of the entire line-up of cars made by the company, this is probably the most ‘rebel’ design you can have today. While all others seem to be exactly the same, making it hard to distinguish between a 3 Series and a 5 Series, the Z4 has a fresh look. Even so, its age is starting to show and compared to all the tech stuff inside the Audi, it’s nowhere close.

The BMW has a lot more engine options available

When it comes to engine/transmission choices, things tip in the favor of the BMW. Sure, the Audi is a new model for now and just 3 engine options were revealed just yet but even so, the TTS was already announced and things aren’t looking good.

The only diesel available for the TT is the 2-liter TDI making 184 HP and 380 Nm (280 lb-ft) of torque, hooked up to a manual 6-speed transmission. On the other side of the fence, the Z4 doesn’t offer a diesel and never did.

Going over the top of the line models, the TT S has a 2-liter turbocharged petrol engine making 310 HP and 380 Nm (280 lb-ft) of torque. It can be hooked up to a manual or automatic 6-speed gearbox but the fastest choice (the auto) can be had with the quattro all-wheel drive system, turning the roadster into a 4.9 second car to 100 km/h (62 mph).

On the other hand, the Z4 sDrive35is is a beast. It has a trademark 3-liter inline 6-cylinder turbocharged engine making 340 HP and 500 Nm (369 lb-ft) of torque, connected to a 7-speed DCT gearbox. With launch control, the rear-wheel drive car will do 100 km/h (62 mph) in just 4.8 seconds.

441495dc32adc2bf8d13a0132254799f.webp

722fa9967999aaad8ec9879e10e80ec3.webp

0c8cf34ad697238e203d4eeca30affd8.webp

238411650808baa607ae260b42d42b2d.webp

08202505ecd51e6a44e86dc975a467a9.webp

Link
 
I would take the Z4. The interiour of the TT is very well. For example I like the solution to integrate the climate control into the vents. But the exterior is ( for me ) to smooth.
 
I would take the Z4 cause it is 1) RWD and thus has the spirit of a true roadster and sports car driving experience 2) I would reckon in real life it will be the best looker as the new Audi TT will be mistaken for previous model as it is so similar looking, especially the rear 3) you have a choice to get a 6 cylinder model with awesome sound and refinement which won't appear in the TT as it will most likely only run 2.0 turbo 4 cylinder engines unless they keep the 2.5 5 cylinder engine for the RS model.

The Audi TT does however have a great interior, I really love the quality look, simplicity combined with high tech look of the instrument cluster.
 
RWD for me please. That twin-turbo motor with DCT must be a blast to play with in a roadster. A perfect combo!
 
Z4 - by a whisker. It's actually a very difficult choice particularly because the Z4 - in spite of some great attributes - is rather flawed in a number of areas whereas you can't really fault the TT-S.
 
Z4 still got the look but its getting old and will be replaced. TT looks more futuristic. I've enjoyed Z4 the times I've driven it, the low seat position is low which you can't say about previous TT. Hopefully that changed with the new TT.
 

Thread statistics

Created
ThroughandThrough,
Last reply from
burana800,
Replies
6
Views
7,413

Trending content

Latest posts


Back
Top