Question.
Let's say you're driving along, and your eyes see neither the HUD nor the conventional speedo. Do you actually save time looking 6 inches higher at the HUD? Either way you're still going to need to break focus and then regain it, no ? Wouldn't that take the same amount of time as well ?
I found an article from year 2007 about HUD advantage/disadvantage:
Head-up Display Advantages
1. Shows you all kind of information that you usually had to look on different dials and can group them all in one place for better functionality. Those HUDs you can see on the market these days, have Bluetooth, GPS and everything that a drive would need to get in time and on the right track to the destination.
2. Data is projected so that they won’t distract the driver’s attention like cellphones or dashboard controls do.
3. Eyes refocus much faster when you switch from the road to the projected display that usually floats 15 feet in front of you
4. Prices are not outrageous as one may think. For a few hundreds you can buy a head-up display that might offer you a safer car.
5. Nowadays HUDs are not really big but they cannot be easily implemented in one’s car with all the controls you need therefore more development is needed.
Head-up Display Disadvantages
1. Such devices will evolve very soon into some kind of portable multimedia that will be able to read your email while driving. Though seeing an email directly on the windshield is safer than using your PDA or your smartphone, it’s still a big distraction.
2. Voice or flashing text could also be distracting for someone driving, because you may want to focus on what the person says or on what the flashing is about.
3. Expect cars to have HUDs installed from 2008 onwards which is at least one year from today. Many of us are anxious to see it running right now, not waiting 1-2 years to get it as a standard on a new car.
4. The optical system that projects your data is complicated and therefore the light efficiency is low. I really wonder how they adjust the HUD projector to be as light in clear sun as when we’re night driving.
--------
If HUD is a safety issue it wouldnt be for sale, pretty simple right? Even cheap japanese cars have HUD as an extra option. Whats more dangerous than HUD is paying atttention to you extern attached navigator and listening to a man's annoying voice.
