Vs The battle of the sedans. (RS6 vs the others)

Vehicle comparisons, matchups, debates, performance battles, and head-to-head discussions.

Your choice?

  • Audi RS6

    Votes: 23 25.3%
  • BMW M5

    Votes: 38 41.8%
  • Mercedes-Benz E63 AMG

    Votes: 19 20.9%
  • Jaguar XF-R

    Votes: 7 7.7%
  • Cadillac CTS-V

    Votes: 4 4.4%

  • Total voters
    91
Re: The battle os the sedans. (RS6 vs the others)

Very simple... M5 gets my vote! How often you guys see a V10 revving over 8000 rpm? :t-cheers:

Some basic reasons;

1: Naturally aspirated.
2: Rwd.
3: A proper 4-door sports-car since day 1.
4: Power to Weight Ratio.
5: Last but not least... it's a Bmw! :cool:
 
Re: The battle os the sedans. (RS6 vs the others)

The M5 for sure. It is by far the best in this group at what I seek in a car - the "fun to drive" factor. Still unbeaten. Maybe in the same way that the S-class is still the best at being what the segment it defines demands.

That said, the M5 has often been slower in a straight line and sometimes also on track but no one has ever come close to what the M5 is all about and that goes for most generation. That is what is so facinating about it.
 
Re: The battle os the sedans. (RS6 vs the others)

Last year or not, the E63 gets my vote, still looks great.
 
Re: The battle os the sedans. (RS6 vs the others)

The Jag and the Rs6 are stunning!

I went to see the facelifted A6 todays and its soo handsome!

And the Jag as well

But I think I'd have to have the Rs6:cool:
 
Re: The battle os the sedans. (RS6 vs the others)

Just to be different, I'll go with the XF-R. The car is gorgous and the new aero kit makes it even more badass.
 
Re: The battle os the sedans. (RS6 vs the others)

Just to be different, I'll go with the XF-R. The car is gorgous and the new aero kit makes it even more badass.

HMMMM someone has spent way too much time in school and needs to get out some. :D
 
Re: The battle os the sedans. (RS6 vs the others)

No, Nate, it's just that I'm not blinded by my love for MB like you. LOL :D

Maybe a little, but I still truthfully think it is the best (for me).
E, RS6, M5, Jag/CTS

The only reason you picked the cat is it is now owned by TATA
 
Re: The battle os the sedans. (RS6 vs the others)

Maybe a little, but I still truthfully think it is the best (for me).
E, RS6, M5, Jag/CTS

The only reason you picked the cat is it is now owned by TATA

C'mon now. The Indians owning TATA now have nothing to do with it. This kitty is still the product of FORD. :t-cheers:
 
I voted for the M5.

To cite that I voted M5 for aesthetic and horsepower reasons would be a bit too...shallow.

;)
 
The RS6 is the ruler for now. But which would be your choice and why?


RS6 ruler? LOL, never! Just because it is a tad bit faster because it has a twin turbo doesn't make it the ruler in any way. The M5 is the better sports sedan, has the better, more responsive engine, chassis, driving characteristics, gearbox....everything.

M5 allllllll the way, without thinking twice :D
 
Re: The battle os the sedans. (RS6 vs the others)

If I am after a high performance wagon, I will pick the RS6, but for a sedan, I will go for the Jag. The RS6 is too heavy, the E63 isn't really sharp enough. The M5 is sharp and light, but I don't really like a high revving engine for normal driving, so it is out. The Jag seems to be a good compromise on paper, and the basic XF already has good handling. I won't make a final vote until I read some road test review on the Jag.
 

Trending content

Latest posts


Back
Top