German Car Forum

The RS6 is the ruler for now. But which would be your choice and why?

Audi RS6:

580hp, 650Nm, 5.0L V10 BiTurbo, 0-100 in 4.5 seconds

BMW M5:

507hp, 520Nm, 5.0L V10, 0-100 in 4.7 seconds

MB E63 AMG:

514hp, 630Nm, 6.2L V8, 0-100 in 4.5 seconds

Jaguar XF-R:

510hp, 625Nm, 5.0L V8, 0-100 in 4.7 seconds

Cadillac CTS-V:

556hp, 551Nm, 6.2L V8, 0-100 in 4.2 seconds

I would choose the Jaguar XF-R here!! Really love it! Great design and "different" to the german competitors! Also great perfomance between 80 - 120 etc!!

Second place would be the E 63 AMG and then RS6!

RS6 for me.
_______________________


Btw: Big comparison test in the new AutoBild Sportscars issue!
(I'll scan the article next week.)

Alpina B5 S vs. Audi RS6 vs. BMW M5 vs. Mercedes-Benz E63 AMG

0-100 km/h:
1. 4,1 s - RS6
2. 4,4 s - E63 AMG
3. 4,7 s - B5 S & M5

0-200 km/h:
1. 13,2 s - RS6
2. 13,5 s - B5 S
3. 13,8 s - M5
4. 14,2 s - E63 AMG

GPS-topspeed:
1. 322 km/h - B5 S
2. 279 km/h - RS6 (limited)
3. 260 km/h - M5 (limited)
4. 250 km/h - E63 AMG (limited)

Weight:
1. 1849 kg - B5 S
2. 1853 kg - M5
3. 1933 kg - E63 AMG
4. 2065 kg - RS6

Sachsenring:
1. 1.42,16 min - RS6
2. 1.43,77 min - M5
3. 1.44,30 min - E63 AMG
4. 1.45,94 min - B5 S

1st: RS6
2nd: M5
3rd: E63 AMG
4th: B5 S

If I could choose between these four, I would go for the Alpina - without thinking twice…

M5 because it's simply unmatched in what it does the best: Taking you to NIRVANA.

I'm going to thumb my nose at the establishment here and go with the CTS-V, XFR and then RS6 in that order. Don't want an E63 or M5 this late in their lives. CTS-V gets my vote for being the first Cadillac that can truly compete with anything in its market segment and in a lot of cases, beat anything in its market segment. Love the new XFR and RS6 would need to drive those 2 to decide between them.


M

Definitely the E63 for me,it is the oldest of the bunch but my god does it look gorgeous and elegant

I would go for the RS6. It's just so brutally fast, and I love the new rear design!

2. E63
3. XR-F
4. M5
5. CTS-V

As a Sedan, M5 is my choice. If its a Kombi then Rs6 is my choice. I won't vote.

You are boring

I'm sure u voted for M5

Seriosly, I havent voted.

If it's a sedan, RS6 is my choice. If it's a Avant, RS6 is my choice. You think I voted?

RS6 is my choice for now. Followed by the XF-R.

But when the new W212 E63 comes out, that will change everything, I can rest assure that.

I'm surprised the E63 is winning. As a Merc fan I have to admit, the W211 E63s time to shine is over. Can't wait until the W212 E63 comes out it will a true beast.

This site has many devoted MB and BMW fans, that will vote for their darlings, no matter what

I've driven both E63 and M5.
Between these two my vote is clear. M5 is more engaging to drive, sounds prettier, sportier gearbox, and have a wonderful highreeving engine.
I've driven previous Rs6, I really want to drive the latest RS6. Something tells me I'm going to love the car.

Jaguar XF-R for me! Best looking out of all of them, in my opinion.

Umm the E63 is to old for me to vote for..
BUt it looks the best of them all STILL

So ile give my vote to the M5..
Its a mighty car..

PS
I dont like the RS6 its to expensive,to late and to dull looking

I'm so impressed by Caddy's effort with the CTS-V that I just have to give my vote to it. CTS-V with the manual for me.

I'd take the RS6 over the E63, and the rest are not to my taste.

Why? u said if it's a sedan then M5 and this poll is about super sedans!

Very simple... M5 gets my vote! How often you guys see a V10 revving over 8000 rpm?

Some basic reasons;

1: Naturally aspirated.
2: Rwd.
3: A proper 4-door sports-car since day 1.
4: Power to Weight Ratio.
5: Last but not least... it's a Bmw!

The M5 for sure. It is by far the best in this group at what I seek in a car - the "fun to drive" factor. Still unbeaten. Maybe in the same way that the S-class is still the best at being what the segment it defines demands.

That said, the M5 has often been slower in a straight line and sometimes also on track but no one has ever come close to what the M5 is all about and that goes for most generation. That is what is so facinating about it.

Last year or not, the E63 gets my vote, still looks great.

The Jag and the Rs6 are stunning!

I went to see the facelifted A6 todays and its soo handsome!

And the Jag as well

But I think I'd have to have the Rs6