German Car Forum

And several reviewers found the contrary.

Autocar on the 118d SE, Test Date 12 October 2004:
"The dashboard is stylishly minimalist, of high quality and intelligently arranged, and it’s comfortably up with the best in the class."
The Car Enthusiast, 2005 120i:
"Interior (4 stars out of 5):
Not as much space in the rear as most of the competition, but excellent fit and finish."
on the 130i Limited Edition:
"The 130i Limited Edition is very well-appointed, with high fit and finish levels complemented by the beautifully tailored leather seats and a host of technological gadgetry, including iDrive and a centre-mounted navigation screen; all of the creature comforts you would expect in a car that breaks the £30,000 mark. The cockpit is a bit confined (especially at the rear), but the tactile quality of the dashboard and centre console - angled toward the driver - is at a high standard."
John Simister, for Independent Online, on the 130i M Sport:
"Inside, rear passenger space is tight and so is the boot, but it's undeniably well made and expensively trimmed."

Auto Motor und Sport Sweden have compared the 120 to the A3 twice (both petrol and diesel versions), and each time gave both of them the same ratings for the interior. Autobild scored the 130i at 15 points out of 20. The S3 demolished the BMW...with 16 points. Similar results in AutoZeitung (185 points to Audi 2.0TDI, 183 points to 120d). There's probably a whole bunch more like that, and quite obviously more so for the face-lifted models and the 1er coupe, but I think that's enough for now.


So, to say that the A3 is far ahead of the 1-Series in interior quality, or that the 1 Series is somehow flimsly while a similarly-specced or -conditioned A3 isn't, sounds like hyperbole of splitting hairs: the A3 may be better, but it's not a world of difference better. Styling is very subjective, and I personally find the A3 interior dated, its upper dash combining with the center console in one piece not attractive. Not to mention many of the hard plastics in the 1-Series can be replaced with aluminum (just as in the A3). I do agree that the exterior styling of the A3 is more instantly palatable, so is likely to appeal more to those of a primarily aesthetic bent.

After he facelift 1 series has an improved interior. Although IMO the plastics are still a bit better on the A3 the difference is not big anymore.

I've been in several A3's before I bought my facelifted 1-series. The quality and interior materials are no differences. The interior in FL 1er is just as good as A3 saying otherwise is ignorant.
We have to wait for next generation A3 before we can say there are "huge" differences between A3 and 1er, now its nothing to argue about. Only thing we can argue about is which design we prefer.

And this thread is?

The oh so super biased bmw badge kisser forum?

Why are you still here if there are so many bmw fans on this board? shouldnt you be on RS6.com, there are more Audi people there for you.

I like this forum overall thats why

I wont let one little negative put me off.

I missed the part where I claimed this thread is anything.

I also missed the part where someone put a gun to you head to read this "oh so super biased bmw badge kisser forum".

Im just letting it be known to all the bimmer guys that the public preffer the A3 convert, just like how they preffered the new RS6 to the M5

Polls on this forum doesnt reflect public opinion.

no other forum does either, how many actually real buyers to you think sit on carboards. thats small % of majority of the real buyers.
The public prefer, let me laugh.

Just because they dont buy something doesnt mean they have a preference. I prefer the brazil football team to the swedish one but you dont see me wanting to live in brazil, or sweden for that matter.

Everyone has a preference, doesnt mean they have to actually go out and buy it.

Let me have a laugh.

What is this? kindergarten? your so called "poll" doesn't prove anything. I'm still laughing becuase the whole discussion is silly.

A poll on a unbiased forum holds more weight than one on this one.

Polls show a trend. Polls is how the media can predict who will win an election. My poll proves two things. Xan you work out what those two things are?

Whatever floats your boat.
I don't care about polls since they doesnt tell the whole truth. It's just something for fanboys to brag about and you are upset because the A3 is losing here so you find another poll/excuse so you feel better.
Don't bother to reply on this post cuase I end the discussion now, its leading nowere. Time to show the mature side.

Something tells me that this topic will not end well..

And I guess you get to decide which is the unbiased forum and which is not.

You can choose a unbiased forum and I will make another thread exactly like this one

Haha you are funny man.

Folks,

This thread is not about what forum has the most or least biased members, this thread is a simple comparison between a BMW and an Audi, and we'd all like for it to stay that way. Lets us stop this discussion as it contributes little to the thread.

Thanks.

You wanna say what?

Bimmer for me please, I want a real trunk ...!

Looking that pic Eni posted I feel Mercedes is missing out here even though the A3 Cabrio isn't coming to the U.S., but still.

M